How to Master the Art of Retro Buttons: Add Vintage Detail to Your Clothes

by

How to Master the Art of Retro Buttons: A Definitive Guide to Adding Vintage Detail to Your Clothes

Retro buttons are more than just a functional closure; they are miniature pieces of art that can transform a garment from ordinary to extraordinary. In a world saturated with fast fashion, the strategic use of vintage buttons is a powerful way to inject personality, history, and a touch of bespoke craftsmanship into your wardrobe. This guide will walk you through the definitive process of sourcing, selecting, and applying retro buttons to elevate your clothing, making it a true reflection of your unique style.

The Foundation: Understanding Retro Button Eras and Materials

Before you can master the application, you must first understand the history and characteristics of the buttons themselves. Each decade has a distinct aesthetic and material preference, which is crucial for achieving an authentic vintage look.

A Journey Through Time: Key Eras and Their Buttons

  • Art Deco (1920s-1930s): This era is defined by geometric shapes, clean lines, and a sense of luxury. Buttons from this period often feature Bakelite, a type of early plastic known for its vibrant colors and marbled patterns. Look for buttons with geometric carvings, chrome accents, and sometimes even small rhinestones. Actionable Tip: Use these buttons on a simple, straight-cut shift dress or the cuffs of a tailored blazer to add a touch of Jazz Age glamour.

  • Mid-Century Modern (1940s-1950s): The post-war era brought a focus on optimism and innovation. Buttons from this time often feature Lucite, a transparent plastic that could be molded into whimsical shapes and colors. You’ll find buttons that look like tiny fruits, flowers, or even abstract “splatter” designs. Actionable Tip: A set of brightly colored Lucite flower buttons can instantly update a plain cardigan or a high-waisted skirt.

  • Mod and Psychedelic (1960s-1970s): This period was all about bold experimentation. Buttons became larger, more colorful, and often featured unique materials like wood, ceramic, and even fabric-covered variations. Look for chunky, oversized buttons in primary colors or psychedelic patterns. Actionable Tip: Replace the standard buttons on a denim jacket with large, colorful wooden buttons to give it a groovy, ’60s feel.

The Material Matters: A Practical Guide

  • Bakelite: This thermosetting plastic has a satisfying weight and a distinct, clinking sound. It’s often marbled and comes in a wide range of colors. To test for authentic Bakelite, rub it vigorously with your thumb until it warms up, then smell it. A faint, chemical “phenol” scent indicates genuine Bakelite.

  • Celluloid: One of the earliest plastics, Celluloid has a lighter, more brittle feel than Bakelite. It can mimic natural materials like ivory or tortoiseshell and often has a pearlescent sheen. Be careful with these, as they are flammable.

  • Lucite: Known for its transparency and vibrant colors, Lucite is a thermoplastic that can be molded into countless shapes. Buttons from this material often have a polished, glass-like appearance.

  • Metal: From intricate filigree to stamped brass, metal buttons offer a timeless appeal. Look for specific finishes like antiqued brass, pewter, or chrome to match the desired era.

The Art of the Swap: Where and How to Find Your Buttons

Finding the perfect retro buttons is a treasure hunt. You won’t find them in a typical craft store. Here’s a detailed guide on where to look and what to look for.

Sourcing Your Vintage Treasures

  • Thrift Stores and Second-Hand Shops: The button jackpot is often found in the most unexpected places. Look for old garments that are beyond repair, such as a moth-eaten coat or a dress with irreparable stains. These often have a goldmine of beautiful buttons that can be salvaged. Actionable Example: Find an old, tweed blazer with stunning horn buttons. Even if the blazer is too worn to wear, you can snip off the buttons and use them on a modern wool coat.

  • Antiques and Flea Markets: These are prime locations for individual buttons and cards of buttons. Don’t be afraid to ask sellers if they have any “button jars” or a box of loose buttons they’re willing to sell. You can often buy a whole bag for a low price and find several gems.

  • Specialty Vintage Button Sellers: Many online and physical shops specialize solely in vintage buttons. While these can be more expensive, they often have rare and highly curated selections, making it easier to find a specific style or a matching set.

A Practical Checklist for Sourcing

  • Check for a Full Set: Ensure you have enough buttons for your project. If you’re replacing buttons on a shirt, you’ll need at least eight, including the cuff buttons. If you’re using them on a coat, you might only need three or four.

  • Inspect for Damage: Check for cracks, chips, or faded color. A chipped Bakelite button is a deal-breaker. A cracked mother-of-pearl button is irreparable.

  • Consider the Shank: The shank is the loop or hole on the back of the button. Some buttons have a “sew-through” shank with two or four holes, while others have a “self-shank” or “loop shank.” This affects how the button lies on the fabric.

  • Look for a “Story”: A button with a little bit of wear, a unique pattern, or a slight patina tells a story. This is the difference between a generic button and a true retro gem.

The Application: Sewing Buttons Like a Professional

The way you attach a button is just as important as the button itself. A poorly sewn button can quickly unravel the vintage aesthetic.

Step-by-Step: Attaching Sew-Through Buttons

  1. Preparation is Key: Mark the exact spot where the button will go. Use a fabric pencil or tailor’s chalk. Make a small “X” to guide your stitches.

  2. Thread Your Needle: Use a strong, all-purpose thread. For extra durability, especially on a coat or jacket, double your thread.

  3. Start from the Inside: Knot your thread and push the needle up through the fabric from the back side, at the top of your “X” mark. This hides the knot.

  4. Create a Shank (The Right Way): Place a toothpick, a matchstick, or a pin on top of the button, between the two holes. This creates a tiny space between the button and the fabric. This “shank” is crucial for allowing the buttonhole to pass over the button easily.

  5. Sewing the Button: Bring the needle up through one hole, over the toothpick, and down through the opposite hole. Repeat this process six to eight times.

  6. Securing the Thread: After the final stitch, bring the needle up, but not through the button. Remove the toothpick. Wind the thread tightly around the stitches underneath the button (the shank you just created) three or four times. This reinforces the shank.

  7. Finishing the Job: Push the needle back through to the inside of the garment, create a small loop, and knot it securely. Snip the excess thread.

Attaching Shank Buttons

  1. Mark the Spot: As with sew-through buttons, mark the exact location.

  2. Start from the Inside: Push the needle up from the back of the fabric, through your mark.

  3. Go Through the Shank: Push the needle through the loop on the back of the button.

  4. Repeat: Push the needle back down into the fabric, making a small stitch. Repeat this process six to eight times.

  5. Creating the Shank: With a shank button, the “shank” is built-in. However, you can still wrap the thread around the base of the button a few times to create a sturdier post.

  6. Finishing: Secure the thread on the inside of the garment with a knot.

Strategic Application: The Power of Placement and Context

A retro button’s impact depends entirely on where and how you use it. Here’s a breakdown of creative and impactful applications.

1. The Full-Garment Revamp

This is the most direct application: replacing all the buttons on a garment with a matching set of retro buttons.

  • Example: A Plain Cardigan: Take a solid-colored, modern cardigan. Remove the generic plastic buttons. Replace them with a set of ten iridescent mother-of-pearl buttons from the 1940s. The simple act of swapping the buttons instantly gives the cardigan a sophisticated, classic feel. The buttons become the focal point.

  • Example: A Winter Coat: Find a simple wool coat. Replace the standard plastic or metal buttons with large, chunky Bakelite buttons from the ’30s. The heavy, colorful buttons will add a touch of Art Deco drama and vintage flair to an otherwise modern silhouette.

2. The Accent Piece

Sometimes, a single retro button is all you need to make a statement.

  • Example: Collar Pins: Sew a single, beautiful vintage button to a stiff backing (like felt) and attach a pin-back. You can now use this as a decorative collar pin on a blouse or blazer. A single ornate metal button from the Edwardian era can add a touch of old-world elegance to a modern silk shirt.

  • Example: Cuffs and Sleeves: Replace only the cuff buttons on a blazer or a shirt. A set of four elegant, small metal buttons on the cuffs can make a powerful, subtle statement without overhauling the entire garment. This is a great way to use buttons when you don’t have a full set.

3. The Decorative Touch

Buttons don’t always have to be functional. They can be purely for decoration.

  • Example: Embellishing a Handbag: Sew a cluster of mismatched, colorful retro buttons in a cascading pattern down the front flap of a simple cloth or leather handbag. Use a mix of Bakelite, Lucite, and metal buttons for a eclectic, personalized look.

  • Example: A Button-Back Detail: On a simple blouse or a dress, replace a few of the back buttons with a contrasting set of large, ornate buttons. The back of the garment becomes a focal point, especially if the piece has a keyhole or slit detail.

4. The Mix-and-Match Method

This advanced technique involves intentionally using non-matching buttons to create a unique, curated aesthetic.

  • Example: A Boho Blouse: On a flowy, bohemian-style blouse, use a different vintage button for each buttonhole. The key is to keep a consistent theme, such as “all small, clear Lucite buttons” or “all different sizes of white mother-of-pearl buttons.” This creates a truly one-of-a-kind garment that tells a story.

  • Example: The Button-Art Denim Jacket: This is for the truly adventurous. Sew a collection of different-sized, different-era buttons onto the collar or pockets of a denim jacket. This creates a textural, sculptural detail that is completely unique.

Troubleshooting and Maintenance

Once your retro buttons are attached, you’ll want to ensure they stay looking their best.

A. Cleaning and Care

  • General Rule: Always remove retro buttons before washing a garment, especially if they are made of delicate materials like Bakelite or celluloid. Hand wash the garment separately.

  • Bakelite and Plastics: A soft cloth and a gentle, non-abrasive cleaner (like mild soap and water) are all you need. Do not use harsh chemicals or abrasive scrubs.

  • Metal: Use a jewelry polishing cloth for metal buttons to restore their shine. Be careful not to get polish on the fabric.

  • Mother-of-Pearl: These buttons are quite durable, but they can chip. Clean them with a soft, damp cloth.

B. Securing Loose Buttons

  • Carry a small sewing kit with you. If you notice a button is getting loose, reinforce the stitches immediately to prevent it from falling off.

  • Always sew an extra button or two onto the inside seam of a garment so you have a spare if one gets lost. This is a standard practice in tailoring and a smart habit to adopt.

C. Choosing the Right Thread

  • Color Match: For a seamless look, use thread that perfectly matches your fabric.

  • Color Contrast: For a more intentional, decorative look, you can use a contrasting thread color. A bright red thread on a white blouse, for example, can highlight the buttonholes and the buttons themselves.

  • Strength: Use a strong, polyester all-purpose thread. Cotton thread can be too weak for heavy buttons.

The Final Touch: A Declaration of Style

Mastering the art of retro buttons is a journey of creativity, resourcefulness, and attention to detail. It’s about seeing beyond the garment and recognizing the potential of every small component. By understanding the history, sourcing your materials with care, and applying them with precision, you can transform your wardrobe into a collection of unique, personalized pieces. This isn’t just about fashion; it’s about making a statement, honoring the past, and creating something that is truly and beautifully your own.