How to Choose the Right Buttons for Your Blazer: A Small Detail, Big Impact

by

Choosing the right buttons for a blazer is a subtle art form, a small detail with a monumental impact on the garment’s overall aesthetic and perceived quality. The buttons are the final touch, the punctuation mark on your sartorial sentence. Get them right, and your blazer looks cohesive, elevated, and intentional. Get them wrong, and even the most perfectly tailored jacket can feel unbalanced or cheap. This guide cuts through the noise, providing a clear, actionable roadmap to selecting the ideal buttons for any blazer, transforming a good jacket into a great one.

The Foundation: Understanding Button Anatomy and Materials

Before we dive into selection, you need to understand what you’re working with. A button is not just a button. Its material, size, and style all play a role.

Common Button Materials and Their Characteristics

  • Horn: The gold standard for classic menswear, horn buttons are made from the horns of animals like buffalo. They possess a natural, rich luster and a unique, marbled texture, meaning no two buttons are exactly alike. They are durable, have a satisfying weight, and are typically the choice for high-end blazers and suits. Look for real horn, not plastic imitations.

  • Corozo: Sourced from the Tagua nut, also known as “vegetable ivory,” Corozo is a sustainable and sophisticated alternative to horn. It has a beautiful, natural grain and a chalky, matte finish that can be polished to a soft sheen. Corozo buttons are extremely durable and take dye well, making them available in a wide range of colors.

  • Metal: Metal buttons, particularly brass, gold, or silver-toned, are a traditional choice for classic navy blazers. They offer a strong contrast and a sense of formality. The best metal buttons are solid, heavy, and often feature an intricate crest or design. They are a statement piece and define the blazer’s aesthetic.

  • Mother-of-Pearl: Made from the iridescent inner layer of mollusk shells, Mother-of-Pearl buttons have a unique, shimmering quality that catches the light. They are a classic choice for lighter-colored blazers, linen jackets, or summer sport coats. They are delicate and elegant but can be more fragile than other materials.

  • Galalith/Casein: An early form of plastic made from milk protein, Galalith buttons have a smooth, dense feel and can be dyed in vibrant colors. They are a good choice for less formal blazers or jackets with a modern, design-forward aesthetic.

  • Plastics (Polyester/Urea): While often seen as a lower-quality option, modern high-grade plastic buttons can be durable and well-made. They are uniform in color and texture and are often used as a cost-effective alternative to horn or Corozo. The key is to look for a button that doesn’t feel flimsy or hollow.

Button Styles: Shank vs. Sew-Through

  • Shank Buttons: These buttons have a small loop or “shank” on the back through which the thread is passed. This creates a space between the button and the fabric, allowing the button to sit neatly over the buttonhole and accommodating thicker fabrics without puckering. This is the most common style for blazers.

  • Sew-Through Buttons: These buttons have two or four holes through which the thread is sewn directly. They lie flat against the fabric and are more common on shirt cuffs, vests, or less formal jackets. For a blazer, a sew-through button would only be appropriate for the cuff, and even then, a shank button is more traditional.

Rule 1: Match the Button’s Formality to the Blazer’s Fabric

This is the most critical rule. A heavy flannel blazer calls for a substantial, weighty button, while a lightweight linen jacket requires something lighter and more delicate.

Example 1: The Formal Flannel Blazer

  • Blazer: A charcoal or navy heavyweight flannel blazer.

  • Correct Button Choice: Large, dark horn buttons with a strong, natural marbling. The weight and texture of the horn complement the thick, textured flannel. A shiny metal button would look jarring, while a mother-of-pearl button would look completely out of place.

Example 2: The Casual Linen Blazer

  • Blazer: A sand-colored or light blue linen blazer.

  • Correct Button Choice: Corozo buttons in a light tan or ecru color. Their chalky, natural finish and lighter weight perfectly match the relaxed, airy feel of the linen. Mother-of-Pearl is another excellent option, as its subtle iridescence adds a touch of elegance without being overpowering.

Example 3: The Classic Navy Blazer

  • Blazer: A hopsack or serge wool navy blazer.

  • Correct Button Choice: Brass or gold-toned metal buttons with a simple crest. This is the quintessential combination. The metallic luster provides a sharp contrast against the deep navy, solidifying its classic, preppy identity.

Rule 2: Consider the Button’s Size and Number

The size of the button must be in proportion to the blazer’s size and lapel width. A large button on a narrow-lapel, slim-fit jacket will look awkward and oversized. Similarly, a tiny button on a broad, wide-lapel jacket will look lost.

  • Body Buttons: For the main closure buttons (typically two or three), aim for a diameter of 24-28 lignes (approximately 15-18 mm). A two-button jacket can handle slightly larger buttons than a three-button jacket, as there’s more space between them.

  • Cuff Buttons: For the four buttons on the cuff, aim for a smaller size, typically 18-20 lignes (approximately 11-13 mm). They should be a miniature version of the main body buttons, maintaining consistency.

Practical Application: Lay the buttons on the blazer before you sew them on. Step back a few feet. Do they look balanced? Do they overpower the jacket or disappear into it? This simple check prevents mistakes.

Rule 3: Coordinate the Button’s Color and Texture with the Blazer

The button’s color should either harmonize or provide a deliberate, complementary contrast.

Harmonizing

This is the safest and most common approach. The button color is a shade or two lighter or darker than the blazer’s fabric, but from the same color family.

  • Example: A dark brown tweed blazer with medium brown horn buttons. The buttons blend in but the natural texture of the horn provides visual interest.

Contrasting

This is a more confident choice that can make a statement. The button color is in direct contrast to the blazer’s color.

  • Example: A charcoal grey blazer with black Corozo buttons. The contrast is subtle but sharp, giving the jacket a modern, minimalist feel.

  • Example: A camel-colored wool blazer with dark brown horn buttons. The buttons pop against the light fabric, anchoring the jacket with a traditional feel.

Rule 4: Pay Attention to the Finish

The button’s finish—whether it’s matte, polished, or textured—is a critical detail that influences the blazer’s formality.

  • Matte Finish: A matte or chalky finish, common in Corozo or unpolished horn, creates a more casual, understated look. It absorbs light rather than reflecting it, making it perfect for tweed, linen, or flannel blazers.

  • Polished Finish: A high-gloss, polished finish, typical of some horn or mother-of-pearl buttons, adds a touch of formality and luster. Use this for smoother fabrics like worsted wool or silk blends.

  • Textured Finish: A button with a visible grain, like horn or wood, adds depth and character. This is ideal for blazers with a textured fabric, like tweed or hopsack, where the textures can play off each other.

The Decision-Making Process: A Step-by-Step Guide

  1. Analyze the Blazer’s Fabric and Formality: Is it a heavyweight wool for winter? A crisp linen for summer? A versatile, year-round worsted wool? This determines the button material.

  2. Determine the Desired Aesthetic: Do you want a classic, traditional look? A modern, minimalist vibe? A bold, contrasting statement? This informs the button color and style.

  3. Source High-Quality Buttons: Don’t skimp here. A cheap plastic button will undermine a well-made blazer. Seek out reputable haberdashery shops or online retailers specializing in buttons. Look for horn, Corozo, or solid metal.

  4. Test the Buttons in Person: If possible, place the buttons on the blazer before sewing. Observe them in different lighting conditions. Does the color work? Is the size right?

  5. Consider the Buttonholes: If you are having a new blazer made or a jacket altered, the buttonholes should be a consideration. A good tailor can match the thread color of the buttonhole to the button, creating a flawless, cohesive look.

The Ultimate Blazer Button Combinations: Concrete Examples

For the Navy Blazer (Versatile Pick)

  • Option 1 (Classic): Solid brass or gold-toned metal buttons with a simple crest. This is the definitive choice for a traditional aesthetic.

  • Option 2 (Modern/Subtle): Dark navy Corozo buttons. This creates a monochromatic, clean look where the buttons blend in, making the blazer more versatile and less formal.

  • Option 3 (Elegant): Dark horn buttons with a subtle blue or grey marbling. This adds a touch of natural texture and sophistication without the formality of metal.

For the Grey Wool Blazer (Business/Smart Casual)

  • Option 1 (Understated): Dark grey or charcoal horn buttons. The natural variation in the horn adds visual interest to a solid grey fabric.

  • Option 2 (Modern Contrast): Black matte Corozo buttons. This combination is sharp, contemporary, and confident.

  • Option 3 (Timeless): Brown horn buttons. The warm tone of the brown provides a pleasing contrast against the cool grey, making it a classic combination.

For the Tweed Sport Coat (Rustic/Casual)

  • Option 1 (Traditional): Brown or tan horn buttons. The natural, earthy tones and texture of the horn perfectly complement the rugged feel of tweed.

  • Option 2 (Unexpected): Dark green or burgundy Corozo buttons. This is a bolder choice that can pick up on a subtle color fleck within the tweed, creating a unique, intentional look.

  • Option 3 (Textural): Leather shank buttons. A very traditional choice for tweed, they add a rich, tactile dimension.

For the Linen/Cotton Summer Blazer (Relaxed/Casual)

  • Option 1 (Natural): Light tan or ivory Corozo buttons. The matte, natural finish is ideal for the laid-back nature of summer fabrics.

  • Option 2 (Refined): Mother-of-pearl buttons. The subtle iridescence adds a touch of quiet luxury, elevating a simple linen jacket.

  • Option 3 (High-Contrast): Dark brown horn buttons. This provides a strong visual anchor and a classic, old-world feel.

Conclusion

The buttons on a blazer are not an afterthought; they are a fundamental part of its design language. By carefully considering the material, size, color, and finish, you can dramatically alter the jacket’s formality, personality, and overall impact. A discerning eye for these small details is what separates a well-dressed individual from the crowd. The right button choice can elevate a basic jacket to a statement piece, making it feel custom and thoughtfully assembled. This guide provides a framework, but the final decision is a matter of personal taste and the story you want your blazer to tell.