How to Shop for Vintage Fashion Like a Pro: 10 Essential Tips

by

Vintage Vulture’s Handbook: 10 Essential Tips for Shopping Vintage Fashion Like a Pro

Shopping vintage fashion isn’t just about buying old clothes; it’s an art form, a treasure hunt, and a sustainable statement all rolled into one. For the uninitiated, vintage racks can feel overwhelming, a sea of mothballs and questionable silhouettes. But for the seasoned pro, it’s a goldmine of one-of-a-kind pieces, superior craftsmanship, and styles that tell a story. This guide is your definitive blueprint, designed to transform you from a hesitant browser into a confident vintage vulture, able to sniff out the gems and build a wardrobe that’s both unique and timeless.

1. Know Your Eras: The Foundation of Your Hunt

Before you even step foot in a vintage store, arm yourself with knowledge. Understanding the defining characteristics of different fashion eras is the single most important skill you can develop. It’s the difference between finding a true 1940s tea dress and mistaking a modern, vintage-inspired piece for the real thing.

How to Do It:

  • Study Silhouettes and Fabrics: Research the iconic shapes of each decade. Think of the 1920s with its dropped waistlines and beading, the 1950s’ cinched waists and full skirts, or the 1980s’ bold shoulders and power suiting. Note the fabrics that were popular. For example, rayon was a key fabric in the 1940s, while polyester became ubiquitous in the 1970s.

  • Create a Mental Checklist: For each era you’re interested in, list three to four defining features. When you see a garment, mentally run through your checklist. Does that dress with the dolman sleeves and geometric print have the feel of the 1980s? Does that structured handbag with the top handle and frame closure look like a 1950s piece?

  • Concrete Example: You’re looking for a 1960s mod dress. You know to look for a shift silhouette, A-line cut, and mini-length hemlines. You also know that bold geometric prints, color-blocking, and synthetic fabrics like Crimplene were popular. Instead of picking up a frilly, lace-trimmed dress that a rookie might think is vintage, you zero in on a sleeveless A-line mini in a bold orange and white zig-zag pattern, confirming its authenticity with the scratchy, synthetic feel of the fabric.

2. Master the Art of the Pre-Shopping Plan

Wandering aimlessly into a vintage store is a recipe for overwhelm and buyer’s remorse. A professional vintage shopper goes in with a mission. This isn’t about being rigid, but about having a clear focus to guide your search and prevent impulse buys.

How to Do It:

  • Identify Your Wardrobe Gaps: Before you go, take a critical look at your current wardrobe. What do you need? A statement jacket? A classic pair of jeans? An evening gown for a special occasion? Shopping with a purpose saves you time and money.

  • Create a “Vintage Wishlist”: This is different from your wardrobe gaps. This is a list of specific, aspirational vintage items you’d love to find. A 1970s embroidered peasant blouse, a 1940s Bakelite bracelet, a pair of 1990s Levi’s 501s. Having a wishlist keeps you excited and gives you a specific item to hunt for.

  • Concrete Example: You’ve identified that your work wardrobe needs a new blazer. You decide to hunt for a high-quality, wool blazer from the 1980s or 1990s. This helps you skip over the racks of casual dresses and focus your energy on the suiting section. You also have a secret wishlist item: a 1950s novelty print skirt. While looking for the blazer, you can keep a peripheral eye out for that unique skirt, making your shopping trip productive and exciting.

3. The Condition Check: Your Most Critical Step

The glamour of a vintage piece can quickly fade when you realize it’s falling apart. A professional knows that a garment’s condition is paramount. Always, always, always inspect an item thoroughly before you consider buying it.

How to Do It:

  • The 360-Degree Rule: Hold the garment up to the light and inspect every inch. Check for holes, tears, and snags. Look at the seams—are they intact? Are there any signs of wear under the arms or around the collar?

  • Zipper and Button Test: Zippers are a common point of failure. Try zipping and unzipping the item a few times. Are all the buttons present and securely attached? Are the buttonholes frayed?

  • Stain and Fading Patrol: Check for yellowing, especially on light-colored fabrics. Look for subtle stains that might not be obvious at first glance. Inspect for uneven fading, which can be a sign of improper storage or a garment that’s seen a lot of sun.

  • Concrete Example: You’ve found a stunning 1950s cocktail dress with intricate beading. Before you get too excited, you put it through the 360-degree rule. You notice a few missing beads, which is acceptable and easily fixable. But then, you spot a large, faint yellow stain on the front bodice and a tear in the seam under the arm. The price is high, and the repair work would be extensive. You make the tough decision to put it back, knowing that a professional knows when to walk away from a project that’s more trouble than it’s worth.

4. The Fit is Everything: Try It On, Always

Vintage sizing is notoriously different from modern sizing. A size 8 from the 1960s is not the same as a size 8 today. Ignoring this fact is the quickest way to end up with a closet full of beautiful clothes that don’t fit.

How to Do It:

  • Bring a Tape Measure: This is a non-negotiable tool for a serious vintage shopper. Take your own measurements (bust, waist, hips, inseam) and keep them written down. When you find a piece you love, measure it directly. Don’t rely on the tag.

  • The Squat and Stretch Test: When trying on pants or skirts, don’t just stand there. Squat down, bend over, and move around. This helps you assess the garment’s mobility and comfort. For tops and dresses, raise your arms and twist your torso to ensure it’s not too tight in the shoulders or back.

  • Assess for Alterations: Look at the inside of the garment. Is there extra seam allowance? Are the hems original, or have they been let down or taken up? A garment with ample seam allowance is a prime candidate for minor alterations if it’s a little snug.

  • Concrete Example: You find a beautiful pair of high-waisted denim jeans from the 1970s. The tag says size 28, which is your modern size. Instead of assuming they fit, you measure them. The waist measures 26 inches, and the hips are a full four inches smaller than your own. You know from your experience that vintage denim has little to no stretch. You also spot a pair of 1990s Levi’s 501s a few racks over. You measure the waist, and it’s a perfect 29 inches. You try them on, and they fit like a glove, confirming that trusting the tape measure over the tag is the smart move.

5. Decode the Labels: Your Secret Language

Labels are more than just a brand name; they are a direct line to the garment’s history and quality. A vintage professional knows how to read them like a detective reads clues.

How to Do It:

  • Look for Union Labels: Garments made in the USA between the 1930s and 1990s often have a union tag, most commonly the International Ladies’ Garment Workers’ Union (ILGWU). These labels can help you narrow down the decade of the item with surprising accuracy.

  • Check the Fabric Content: The fabric tag tells you everything. Natural fibers like wool, silk, and cotton are often more valuable and durable. The presence of specific synthetic materials like rayon, nylon, or polyester can help you place the item in a specific era.

  • Research Obscure Brands: Don’t just dismiss a brand you don’t recognize. Snap a picture of the label and do a quick search on your phone. You might discover a forgotten designer or a high-end department store that was popular in a certain era, giving you an indication of the garment’s quality and value.

  • Concrete Example: You’ve found a chic, knee-length pencil skirt. The label is a tiny, faded tag you don’t recognize. However, you spot a white ILGWU tag with a specific pattern. A quick search reveals that this particular tag design was used from 1964 to 1974. You also see that the fabric content is 100% worsted wool. You now know this is a high-quality, authentic piece from the mid-to-late 1960s, justifying the slightly higher price tag.

6. Bargain and Haggle with Grace

The price on the tag isn’t always the final price, especially in smaller, independent vintage shops or at flea markets. A confident vintage shopper knows when and how to negotiate for a better deal without being disrespectful.

How to Do It:

  • Know the Value: This ties back to your research. If you know the average price for a similar item online, you have leverage. Don’t lowball, but have a realistic idea of what you’re willing to pay.

  • Bundle Up: The easiest way to get a discount is to buy multiple items. Ask the shop owner, “If I buy these three pieces, would you be able to offer a small discount?” This is a win-win for both of you.

  • Point Out Minor Flaws: If you find a small, fixable flaw (a missing button, a frayed hem, a small stain), you can use it to negotiate. Say, “I love this piece, but I’ll have to take it to my tailor to fix this small tear. Would you be able to come down a few dollars on the price?” This is fair and reasonable.

  • Concrete Example: You’ve found a beautiful 1940s wool suit with a price tag of $150. You know that a similar suit in good condition online sells for around $180-$250. You also notice that one of the buttons is a replacement and the cuff on the jacket needs a small stitch. You politely approach the shop owner and say, “I’m interested in this suit and the scarf over there. I noticed the button needs to be replaced and the cuff repaired. Would you be willing to do a bundle price of $140 for both?” The shop owner agrees, and you’ve scored two items for a great price while showing respect for their inventory.

7. Think Beyond the Tagged Size: The Art of Repurposing

The most incredible vintage finds aren’t always in your size. A true professional has a creative eye, seeing a garment not just for what it is, but for what it could be. This is where your tailor becomes your best friend.

How to Do It:

  • Oversized is an Opportunity: A beautiful vintage silk blouse that’s too big can be expertly cinched at the waist with a belt or tucked into a high-waisted skirt. A men’s oversized blazer can be worn as a trendy, boyfriend-style jacket.

  • Look for “Fixer-Uppers”: Can that dress be shortened into a top? Can a long skirt be turned into a mini? Can that ornate tablecloth be transformed into a unique skirt or blouse? Look at fabric, print, and construction, not just the finished product.

  • Embrace Your Tailor: A good tailor is an invaluable resource. Before buying an oversized piece, ask yourself: Can this be taken in? Can the sleeves be shortened? Is the hem easily adjustable? A simple alteration can completely transform a vintage piece from ill-fitting to custom-made.

  • Concrete Example: You find a stunning 1970s embroidered maxi dress. The print is incredible, but the dress is a size too big and a little too long for your taste. You realize the beautiful embroidery is concentrated on the bodice and a little on the skirt. You buy it with the plan to take it to your tailor. She shortens it to a knee-length cocktail dress and takes in the sides. The result is a one-of-a-kind, perfectly fitting dress that no one else has.

8. Focus on Quality Construction and Fabric

The reason so many vintage pieces have survived for decades is because they were built to last. A professional understands that superior craftsmanship is a non-negotiable hallmark of a truly valuable vintage item.

How to Do It:

  • Examine the Seams: Are the seams finished? Look for French seams or serged edges. Raw seams are a sign of lower quality. Look for double stitching in high-stress areas like the crotch and underarms.

  • Check the Lining: Is the garment lined? A quality lining (especially in blazers, coats, and dresses) adds to the longevity and drape of the garment. Is the lining sewn in cleanly?

  • Feel the Fabric: Trust your sense of touch. Does the wool feel rich and soft, or scratchy and thin? Does the silk have a good weight and drape? Does the cotton feel crisp and substantial?

  • Concrete Example: You’re looking at two trench coats. One is a modern, fast-fashion version, and the other is a vintage Burberry. The modern coat is made of a thin, flimsy polyester blend. The seams are unfinished, and it’s unlined. The vintage Burberry, on the other hand, is a heavy, durable cotton gabardine. The seams are perfectly finished, it’s fully lined with a high-quality material, and the buttons are sewn on with an anchor stitch. The vintage piece is a better investment, built to last for another 50 years.

9. Start Small and Build Your Collection Strategically

Vintage shopping can be addictive. To avoid a closet full of random, unwearable pieces, a professional begins by strategically building a foundation of versatile vintage staples.

How to Do It:

  • Begin with Accessories: Accessories are an excellent entry point into vintage. They are generally less expensive, easier to size, and can instantly elevate a modern outfit. Look for vintage scarves, belts, handbags, and jewelry.

  • Hunt for Timeless Silhouettes: Start your clothing collection with classic, iconic pieces that will always be in style. A quality leather biker jacket, a well-fitting pair of high-waisted denim, a classic blazer, or a simple LBD from any era are all great starting points.

  • Focus on One Era at a Time: If you’re passionate about 1970s fashion, dedicate your initial hunts to finding those perfect bell bottoms, platform shoes, and bohemian blouses. This gives your collection a cohesive feel.

  • Concrete Example: You’ve decided to start your vintage journey. Instead of buying a flashy 1980s prom dress, you begin by hunting for a few key items. You find a pair of vintage leather boots that are scuffed but well-made. You then find a buttery soft leather belt from the 1990s. Next, you score a high-quality wool cardigan from the 1950s. These pieces all integrate seamlessly into your existing wardrobe, adding a vintage touch without requiring a complete overhaul.

10. The Power of Maintenance: Care for Your Treasures

A vintage professional understands that the purchase is only the first step. Proper care and maintenance are what keep these pieces wearable and beautiful for years to come.

How to Do It:

  • Know Your Materials: Different fabrics require different care. Silk and wool often need to be dry-cleaned or hand-washed with a specific detergent. Cotton and linen are more durable. Research the proper care for each material you buy.

  • Proper Storage is Key: Don’t just cram your vintage pieces into a packed closet. Use padded hangers for delicate garments to prevent shoulder bumps. Store knits folded to prevent stretching. Keep vintage furs and leathers in breathable garment bags, never plastic.

  • Address Flaws Immediately: If you find a loose button or a tiny seam tear, don’t put it off. Fix it immediately. Procrastination leads to bigger, more irreversible problems.

  • Concrete Example: You’ve just purchased a beautiful 1920s flapper dress with delicate beading. Instead of throwing it in the washing machine, you take it to a specialist dry cleaner who has experience with vintage garments. You then store it in a breathable cotton garment bag, away from direct sunlight, with a sachet of lavender to keep moths away. This ensures your treasured piece remains in pristine condition, ready for its next outing.