Mixing and matching patterns is a skill that elevates an outfit from good to exceptional. While many shy away from this sartorial challenge, mastering the art of combining textures and prints, especially with a classic like herringbone, opens up a world of stylistic possibilities. This guide will take you beyond the basics, providing a clear, practical roadmap to confidently pair herringbone with a variety of other fabrics, ensuring your look is sophisticated and intentional, never chaotic.
The Foundation: Understanding Herringbone
Before we begin mixing, let’s understand the herringbone fabric itself. Its defining characteristic is the distinctive V-shaped weaving pattern, resembling the skeleton of a herring fish. This angular texture adds visual interest and depth, making it a powerful foundation for any outfit. Herringbone comes in various weights and materials, from lightweight cottons perfect for summer blazers to heavy wools ideal for winter coats. The key to mixing is to treat herringbone not just as a pattern, but as a textured neutral. It’s a versatile base that can be dressed up or down, and its inherent structure provides a strong anchor for more playful or softer fabrics.
The Rule of Three: Your Guiding Principle
When combining patterns, the “Rule of Three” is your best friend. This isn’t a rigid law, but a helpful guideline. It suggests using three key elements in your outfit to create a harmonious balance:
- A Dominant Pattern: This is your focal point, the largest or most prominent pattern. In our case, the herringbone is often this dominant pattern.
-
A Secondary Pattern: This pattern should be different in scale from the dominant one. If your herringbone is fine and small, choose a larger, more open pattern here.
-
A Solid Anchor: The solid element provides a visual break, preventing the outfit from looking too busy. This could be a solid shirt, trousers, or a key accessory.
This framework prevents a “too-much-going-on” feeling and gives your eye a place to rest.
Strategic Pairing 1: Herringbone with Stripes
Stripes are arguably the easiest pattern to pair with herringbone because of their linear nature. The key here is contrast in scale and orientation.
The Playbook:
- Vary the Scale: If you have a fine, tightly woven herringbone jacket, pair it with a broader, bolder stripe. A pinstripe shirt, for example, would clash due to its similar thinness. Instead, opt for a wider Bengal stripe or a rugby stripe. The contrast in thickness creates visual separation and interest.
-
Vary the Orientation: A common mistake is to pair horizontal stripes with herringbone without considering the effect. The V-shape of herringbone has a diagonal, directional quality. To complement this, try a shirt with vertical stripes. The two patterns, one diagonal and one vertical, create a dynamic, yet balanced, look.
-
Example 1 (Business Casual): A charcoal herringbone sport coat over a light blue and white Bengal stripe button-down shirt. The wide stripes on the shirt prevent the outfit from looking too busy, and the solid trousers (navy or gray) provide the necessary anchor.
-
Example 2 (Relaxed Weekend): A herringbone blazer (in a looser weave, perhaps a wool-blend) layered over a classic navy and white Breton striped t-shirt. The simplicity of the tee’s stripes balances the intricate weave of the blazer. Finish with dark denim jeans.
Strategic Pairing 2: Herringbone with Checks and Plaid
This is where things get more advanced, but the results can be incredibly stylish. Combining herringbone with checks and plaid requires careful consideration of color and scale.
The Playbook:
- Color Harmony is King: The most successful pairings here involve a shared color palette. Look for a plaid that includes one of the colors present in your herringbone. For instance, if you have a brown herringbone jacket with subtle flecks of green, choose a plaid shirt that also features a shade of green.
-
Scale Contrast is Crucial: This cannot be overstated. A large-scale windowpane check shirt will pair beautifully with a fine herringbone jacket. Conversely, a bolder, larger herringbone pattern (like on an overcoat) works well with a small-scale gingham or micro-check shirt. The difference in size keeps the patterns from competing.
-
The Power of the Solid: When combining these two intricate patterns, the rest of your outfit must be simple. Stick to solid-colored trousers and a tie (if you’re wearing one) that picks up a color from either the herringbone or the plaid.
-
Example 1 (Classic Office): A medium-gray herringbone suit paired with a crisp white and blue gingham shirt. The small-scale gingham provides just enough pattern without overwhelming the suit. Complete the look with a solid navy tie.
-
Example 2 (Smart Casual): A brown herringbone overcoat draped over a simple white t-shirt and a pair of trousers. The overcoat is the dominant pattern, so your secondary pattern is the tartan scarf. Choose a scarf with a few colors, including a shade of brown that complements the coat, and let it hang loosely.
Strategic Pairing 3: Herringbone with Paisleys and Floral Prints
This is a high-reward, high-risk combination. The key is to treat the paisley or floral as an accent, not a co-star. The herringbone must be the clear star of the show.
The Playbook:
- Let Herringbone Be the Anchor: Use a herringbone piece as the foundational, stabilizing element. A suit, a blazer, or even a pair of herringbone trousers can serve this purpose.
-
Accent with a Small Dose: The paisley or floral should appear in a smaller dose. A tie, a pocket square, or a scarf are ideal vehicles for these more intricate, curvilinear patterns. A full-on floral shirt under a herringbone blazer can be difficult to pull off unless the floral print is very subdued and the blazer is a simple, muted color.
-
Color is Your Compass: The paisley or floral print should have a color that is present in the herringbone. For example, a brown herringbone jacket with a subtle dark red hue would look great with a paisley tie that also features that same dark red. This creates a cohesive color story.
-
Example 1 (Formal Evening): A charcoal herringbone suit, a solid white dress shirt, and a silk paisley tie with shades of burgundy and deep blue. The tie is a vibrant accent against the classic, textured backdrop of the suit.
-
Example 2 (Creative Casual): A pair of gray herringbone trousers paired with a simple black t-shirt and a floral-print bomber jacket worn open. The trousers are the anchor, and the floral jacket adds a modern, artistic touch.
Strategic Pairing 4: Herringbone with Knits and Textured Solids
Sometimes, the best way to “mix and match” is to focus on texture rather than just pattern. Pairing herringbone with other textured fabrics creates a rich, tactile look that is both sophisticated and deeply personal.
The Playbook:
- Contrast is Key: Think about the texture of the herringbone. A fine, smooth wool herringbone works well with a chunky knit sweater. The contrast in texture is visually interesting and inviting.
-
Embrace the Tactile: A herringbone blazer over a cable-knit sweater, a herringbone overcoat over a cashmere turtleneck, or a herringbone jacket over a ribbed-knit polo. Each of these combinations leverages the differing feel and look of the fabrics.
-
Color Depth: Use color to enhance the texture. A solid, deep-hued cashmere turtleneck (like navy or burgundy) will look incredibly rich under a gray herringbone jacket. The color itself adds depth, but the luxurious texture of the cashmere elevates it further.
-
Example 1 (Autumnal Elegance): A brown herringbone sport coat layered over a cream-colored, chunky cable-knit sweater. The textures complement each other, and the earthy colors create a warm, inviting aesthetic. Dark denim or corduroy trousers would complete this look.
-
Example 2 (Modern Minimalism): A charcoal herringbone suit with a lightweight, merino wool turtleneck instead of a shirt and tie. The smooth, refined texture of the merino contrasts with the structured herringbone, creating a modern, minimalist silhouette.
Strategic Pairing 5: Herringbone with Denim and Leather
This is the ultimate high-low combination, blending a classic, tailored pattern with rugged, everyday materials. The contrast creates a powerful and stylish statement.
The Playbook:
- The Jacket is the Hero: A herringbone blazer or sport coat is the perfect piece to pair with denim. It instantly elevates the jeans, adding a touch of sophistication. This is a go-to formula for smart casual dress.
-
Choose the Right Denim: Dark, clean, and well-fitting denim (no rips or heavy distressing) is the best choice. It provides a solid, simple base that doesn’t compete with the herringbone. Lighter washes can work, but they are more casual and require a more relaxed herringbone piece.
-
Integrate Leather: Leather can be integrated as a secondary element. A leather belt, a pair of leather boots, or a leather-trimmed bag can add a touch of toughness that complements the herringbone’s classicism. Avoid a full leather jacket over herringbone unless the textures are very different and the colors are a perfect match.
-
Example 1 (Classic High-Low): A gray herringbone blazer over a simple white t-shirt, dark raw denim jeans, and brown leather Chelsea boots. This is a timeless, effortless look that’s perfect for a weekend outing or a casual dinner.
-
Example 2 (Edgy Sophistication): A pair of herringbone trousers with a black turtleneck sweater and a black leather moto jacket. The herringbone adds a touch of classic tailoring, while the leather jacket brings a modern, edgy vibe.
The Finishing Touches: Accessories as Your Secret Weapon
Accessories are not an afterthought; they are the final piece of the puzzle that brings everything together.
- The Tie: When mixing a herringbone suit or jacket with a patterned shirt, your tie should ideally be a solid color that picks up a shade from either pattern. If you’re wearing a solid shirt, this is your chance to introduce another pattern (like a paisley or repp stripe tie) as long as it contrasts in scale.
-
The Pocket Square: A pocket square is a great way to add a pop of color or a subtle pattern. A silk pocket square with a print can add a touch of flair without overwhelming the outfit.
-
Footwear: Your shoes should anchor the look. A classic pair of brown leather brogues with a tweed herringbone jacket is a timeless combination. For a more modern feel, pair a herringbone blazer with a clean pair of white leather sneakers.
The Confident Conclusion
Mastering the art of mixing and matching herringbone with other fabrics is about understanding the principles of contrast—in scale, texture, and color. By treating the herringbone as a sophisticated neutral, a textured anchor for your outfit, you can confidently introduce other patterns and textures to create a look that is layered, thoughtful, and uniquely yours. Start simple, with stripes or checks, and as you gain confidence, venture into the world of paisley and knits. The key is to experiment, pay attention to the details, and remember that style is a personal expression.