How to Choose the Right Eyeliner Color: Beyond Black and Brown

by

A Stroke of Genius: The Ultimate Guide to Choosing the Right Eyeliner Color (Beyond Black and Brown)

For decades, the makeup world has operated under a simple, unspoken rule: eyeliner means black, or maybe brown if you’re feeling adventurous. But what if we told you that the perfect flick of color could do more than just define your eyes? What if it could enhance their natural hue, brighten your entire face, and even make you look more awake? Welcome to the new era of eyeliner, where a spectrum of shades awaits. This guide will take you beyond the basics, providing a definitive, actionable roadmap to choosing the eyeliner color that doesn’t just work for you, but works wonders.

Unlocking the Power of Your Eye Color: The Foundation of Your Choice

The most effective way to choose an eyeliner color is to first understand the color you’re working with: your eyes. The principles of color theory, specifically complementary and analogous colors, are your secret weapon. Complementary colors sit opposite each other on the color wheel and create a striking contrast, making each other pop. Analogous colors are next to each other on the color wheel and create a harmonious, subtle effect.

Blue Eyes: Making the Sky Sparkle

Blue eyes, ranging from a pale seafoam to a deep sapphire, are a beautiful canvas for color. The goal is to make the blue appear more vibrant and intense.

  • Complementary Colors (The “Pop” Effect): The direct opposite of blue on the color wheel is orange. Don’t worry, this doesn’t mean you need to wear neon orange liner. Instead, think of shades with a strong orange or reddish undertone.
    • Actionable Examples:
      • Copper & Bronze: A metallic copper or warm bronze liner will create a stunning contrast, making the blue of your eyes look brighter and more brilliant. For a daytime look, a subtle bronze pencil can be smudged along the lash line. For evening, a shimmery copper liquid liner can deliver a dramatic, eye-catching wing.

      • Terra Cotta & Burnt Orange: These earthy, reddish-orange shades can be applied subtly for a surprising pop of color. A matte terra cotta pencil on the lower water line can be an unexpected and beautiful way to make your eyes look clearer and bluer.

  • Analogous Colors (The “Enhanced” Effect): Colors in the same family, like greens and purples, can create a rich, layered look.

    • Actionable Examples:
      • Navy & Cobalt: A deep navy liner enhances the coolness of blue eyes without the harshness of black. A slick of navy liquid liner can make your blue eyes appear even more intense.

      • Emerald & Teal: While these aren’t directly next to blue, they share a similar cool tone. A jewel-toned emerald liner can bring out any green flecks in your blue eyes, adding a unique dimension.

Green Eyes: Igniting the Emerald Fire

Green eyes are a rare and captivating hue. The right eyeliner can either make them look more forest-like and intense or bring out any gold or brown undertones.

  • Complementary Colors (The “Pop” Effect): The color opposite green on the color wheel is red. Again, this doesn’t mean a fire-engine red liner. Instead, focus on shades with a reddish or reddish-purple base.
    • Actionable Examples:
      • Burgundy & Maroon: A deep, reddish-brown burgundy liner is a classic choice for green eyes. It provides a striking contrast that makes the green appear richer and more vibrant. Use a burgundy gel liner for a precise line or a smudged maroon pencil for a smoky effect.

      • Plum & Aubergine: These deep purple shades with reddish undertones are a universal favorite for green eyes. They are less intense than a true red but still deliver that beautiful complementary contrast. A deep plum pencil can be used for a soft, smoky look.

  • Analogous Colors (The “Enhanced” Effect): Shades of green and blue can create a cohesive, monochromatic look that makes the eyes appear more vibrant.

    • Actionable Examples:
      • Moss & Khaki: A muted, earthy green liner can create a subtle, sophisticated look. A khaki green pencil smudged along the lower lash line can enhance the natural green without being overpowering.

      • Teal & Turquoise: These shades can be used for a more dramatic, jewel-toned effect. A flash of turquoise liquid liner in the inner corner can create a surprising pop of color that beautifully complements the green.

Brown Eyes: The Ultimate Chameleon

Brown eyes, from a warm honey to a deep espresso, are the most versatile. They can be enhanced by nearly any color, as the goal is to bring out the unique warmth and depth within them.

  • Complementary Colors (The “Pop” Effect): The opposite of brown on the color wheel is less defined, but by looking at the undertones of brown (often a mix of red, yellow, and blue), we can find complementary shades. Blue is often considered the most striking contrast.
    • Actionable Examples:
      • Navy & Cobalt: A deep navy liner makes warm, amber-brown eyes look more golden and vibrant. It’s a sophisticated alternative to black that still provides definition. For a bold look, a cobalt blue liquid liner creates a powerful, high-impact contrast.

      • Violet & Lavender: Purple shades are incredibly flattering on brown eyes. They highlight the warmth and can make the brown appear more golden or hazel. A vibrant violet liquid liner can be used for a bold wing, while a lavender pencil can be used for a more playful, whimsical look.

  • Warm & Earthy Tones (The “Enhanced” Effect): Shades that share a similar warmth with brown eyes will create a harmonious, rich effect.

    • Actionable Examples:
      • Bronze & Gold: Metallic shades like bronze and gold are a perfect match for brown eyes. They add a beautiful shimmer and can bring out any gold or amber flecks. A shimmery gold pencil on the lower lash line or inner corner is a simple way to instantly brighten the eyes.

      • Olive & Forest Green: Green eyeliner can bring out the warmth and richness of brown eyes. An olive green smudged along the lash line is a sophisticated, understated choice.

Hazel Eyes: The Dynamic Duo

Hazel eyes are a unique mix of green, brown, and gold. The key to choosing eyeliner is deciding which color you want to emphasize.

  • To Emphasize the Green: Treat your eyes like green eyes. Use shades that are complementary to green.
    • Actionable Examples:
      • Burgundy & Plum: These reddish-purple tones will make the green in your hazel eyes stand out more prominently.

      • Bronze & Copper: The warmth of these metallics can also enhance the green while bringing out any gold flecks.

  • To Emphasize the Brown/Gold: Treat your eyes like brown eyes. Use shades that are complementary to brown.

    • Actionable Examples:
      • Navy & Teal: The coolness of these blue-based shades will create a striking contrast with the warmth of the brown and gold, making them appear richer.
  • To Emphasize Both: Use a combination of colors.
    • Actionable Examples:
      • Two-Toned Liner: Use a plum liner on your upper lash line to make the green pop and a bronze or gold pencil on your lower lash line to bring out the warmth. This creates a multi-dimensional look.

Beyond Eye Color: Other Factors to Consider for a Flawless Look

While eye color is the most important factor, a few other considerations can refine your choice and ensure your eyeliner looks perfect in any situation.

Skin Tone & Undertone: Your Canvas

Your skin tone and undertone play a significant role in how a color will appear on your face. A color that looks great on someone with a cool undertone might look chalky or harsh on someone with a warm undertone.

  • Warm Undertones (Golden, Peachy):
    • Ideal Colors: Shades with a golden or bronze base. Think olive green, rich brown, bronze, and warm navy. These colors will harmonize with your skin and create a luminous effect.

    • Avoid: Cool, ashy grays or icy blues, which can sometimes appear to wash you out.

    • Actionable Examples: A bronze metallic liner will give a beautiful, sun-kissed glow to someone with a warm undertone.

  • Cool Undertones (Pink, Reddish, Blue):

    • Ideal Colors: Shades with a cool or blue base. Think charcoal gray, deep plum, cobalt blue, and emerald green. These colors will beautifully complement your skin’s natural coolness.

    • Avoid: Warm, rusty oranges or yellow-based greens, which can look jarring.

    • Actionable Examples: A deep plum liner will look incredibly sophisticated and rich on someone with a cool undertone, especially if they have green or hazel eyes.

  • Neutral Undertones:

    • Ideal Colors: You’re lucky—you can pull off almost anything. Experiment with both warm and cool shades. The best approach is to choose based on your eye color and the desired effect.

The Occasion: From Boardroom to Bar

The context of your makeup is just as important as the colors themselves. A bold, electric blue wing might not be appropriate for a Monday morning meeting, but it could be the perfect statement for a night out.

  • For the Office/Daytime:
    • Actionable Examples: Opt for subtle, muted shades. A dark gray, a muted navy, or a deep olive green can provide definition without being distracting. Use a pencil to create a soft, smudged line for a more natural look. A matte finish is generally more professional than a shimmer.
  • For a Night Out/Special Occasions:
    • Actionable Examples: This is your time to be bold. Experiment with metallics, shimmers, and bright colors. A shimmering copper wing for blue eyes, a glittery purple for green eyes, or a graphic cobalt line for brown eyes can all create a stunning, high-impact look. Liquid liners are excellent for creating sharp, dramatic wings.

Makeup Style & Desired Effect: Your Personal Vision

What kind of look are you trying to achieve? Your eyeliner color can be the key to tying your entire look together or making a single, powerful statement.

  • To Create a Soft, Romantic Look:
    • Actionable Examples: Use a smudged pencil liner in a soft shade like plum or charcoal. A matte or satin finish will be less harsh than a glossy liquid liner.
  • To Create a Dramatic, Modern Look:
    • Actionable Examples: Go for a sharp, graphic line with a liquid liner. Bold colors like cobalt or emerald can be used to create a floating crease line or an artistic wing.
  • To Create a Subtle, Defined Look:
    • Actionable Examples: Use a dark but not-quite-black shade like espresso brown or slate gray. Tightlining (applying liner to the upper water line) with a dark pencil can create the illusion of fuller lashes without any obvious liner on the lid.

A Practical Playbook: Putting It All Together

Choosing the right color is an art, but it’s also a science. Follow this step-by-step process to ensure you’re making the best choice for you.

  1. Identify Your Eye Color and Undertone: Take a close look at your eyes in natural light. Do they have green flecks? Are they more golden? Also, check the veins on your wrist—blue veins indicate a cool undertone, green veins indicate a warm undertone, and a mix indicates a neutral undertone.

  2. Determine Your Goal: Do you want to make your eyes “pop” and stand out (complementary colors), or do you want to create a more harmonious, subtle enhancement (analogous colors)?

  3. Consider the Occasion: Is this for a professional setting or a special event? This will help you decide between a bold, shimmery liquid and a subtle, matte pencil.

  4. Experiment! The best way to find your perfect shade is to try it. Head to a store with testers and swatch different colors on the back of your hand. Look for colors that feel right and bring out the beauty in your eyes. Don’t be afraid to try a shade that seems unconventional. You might be surprised by what you discover.

The Finishing Stroke: Your Guide to a Polished Look

Once you’ve chosen your color, there are a few final tips to ensure your eyeliner looks flawless.

  • Pairing with Eyeshadow: When wearing a colored liner, consider using a neutral eyeshadow to let the liner be the star of the show. A simple wash of a matte beige or a soft shimmer can be the perfect backdrop. If you’re going for a more complex look, ensure your eyeshadow and eyeliner colors don’t clash.

  • Liner Formulation Matters:

    • Pencil: Best for a soft, smudged look. It’s forgiving and great for beginners.

    • Liquid: Best for a sharp, precise line or a dramatic wing. It’s more intense and long-lasting.

    • Gel/Pot: A versatile middle ground. You can use an angled brush to create a sharp line or smudge it out for a softer look.

Choosing the right eyeliner color is about more than just aesthetics; it’s about empowerment. It’s about taking a simple tool and using it to enhance your natural beauty, express your personality, and feel confident. So, step away from the black and brown, and start exploring the world of color. A single stroke can change everything.