How to Advocate for Sustainable Practices in Modal Production

by

A Comprehensive Guide to Advocating for Sustainable Modal Production in the Fashion Industry

The fashion industry is undergoing a seismic shift, driven by a global demand for transparency and responsibility. At the heart of this movement lies a critical need to scrutinize and improve the environmental and social impact of every textile. Modal, a semi-synthetic cellulose fiber known for its luxurious drape and softness, is often positioned as a sustainable alternative to conventional cotton or synthetics. However, the true sustainability of modal is not inherent; it is entirely dependent on the practices and principles of its production.

This in-depth guide is a roadmap for those who want to move beyond passive consumption and become active advocates for a truly sustainable modal supply chain. It is not an academic treatise on environmental science, but a practical, actionable manual for creating tangible change. We will deconstruct the key areas of modal production—from forest to fiber—and provide a detailed blueprint for how consumers, employees, and industry professionals can exert influence, demand accountability, and drive the industry towards a more regenerative future. This is a call to action for anyone who believes that a beautiful garment should not come at the expense of our planet.

Understanding the Pillars of Sustainable Modal Production

Before you can advocate effectively, you must understand what you are advocating for. Sustainable modal production is not a singular action but a holistic system built on three interconnected pillars: responsible sourcing, closed-loop processing, and a commitment to circularity.

1. Responsible Sourcing: From Forest to Fiber

Modal is derived from beech tree pulp. The sustainability of this process begins in the forest itself. Unsustainable practices, such as deforestation of ancient and endangered forests, monoculture plantations, and the use of harmful pesticides, can negate any perceived environmental benefits of the final fiber.

  • What to Advocate For: Demand that brands use modal sourced from sustainably managed forests.

  • Concrete Action Steps:

    • Prioritize FSC and PEFC Certified Wood Pulp: The Forest Stewardship Council (FSC) and the Programme for the Endorsement of Forest Certification (PEFC) are two of the most respected third-party certifications for responsible forestry. They ensure that forests are managed in an environmentally appropriate, socially beneficial, and economically viable manner. When engaging with brands, ask them directly if their modal suppliers are certified by one of these organizations. For example, a consumer can send an email to a brand with the subject line “Question about Modal Sourcing” and ask, “I love your Modal dress, but I’m concerned about the environmental impact. Can you confirm if the wood pulp used for your Modal is FSC or PEFC certified?”

    • Reference the Canopy “Hot Button” Report: The non-profit organization Canopy releases an annual “Hot Button” report that ranks the world’s top viscose and modal producers based on their commitment to protecting ancient and endangered forests. This is an invaluable tool for advocacy. Use this report to commend brands that work with “green shirt” ranked suppliers, such as Lenzing, and to challenge those that do not. A brand employee, for instance, could use this report in an internal presentation to their procurement team, highlighting the reputational risk of working with low-ranked suppliers and the marketing opportunity of partnering with a top performer.

2. Closed-Loop Processing: A Chemical Revolution

The conversion of wood pulp into a soft textile fiber is a chemical-intensive process. Traditional methods, particularly those used for conventional viscose (a close cousin of modal), can release toxic chemicals like carbon disulfide into local ecosystems, harming both the environment and factory workers. The key to sustainable modal is a closed-loop system.

  • What to Advocate For: Demand that brands partner with suppliers who utilize closed-loop production processes.

  • Concrete Action Steps:

    • Focus on TENCEL™ Modal and Lenzing: The most prominent and widely recognized example of closed-loop modal production is the TENCEL™ Modal fiber from the Austrian company Lenzing. Their process recycles up to 95% of the chemicals and water used, significantly reducing emissions and waste. Advocate for brands to explicitly state that they use TENCEL™ Modal. When a brand’s website simply says “modal,” a savvy consumer can comment on their social media, asking, “Is this TENCEL™ Modal from Lenzing? Closed-loop production is important to me, and I’d love to know more about your supply chain.”

    • Encourage Transparency and Auditing: Push for brands to go beyond simple claims and provide evidence. This could mean requesting third-party audits of their manufacturing facilities to verify that their closed-loop systems are functioning as promised. A supply chain manager within a fashion company could push for a new policy that requires all modal suppliers to undergo a third-party audit of their chemical and water management processes before being approved as a vendor.

3. Circularity and End-of-Life: From Garment to Garment

A truly sustainable material considers its entire lifecycle, including what happens after the consumer is done with it. The fast fashion model of “take, make, waste” is the antithesis of circularity. Modal’s natural biodegradability is a significant advantage, but true circularity goes further, exploring garment-to-garment recycling.

  • What to Advocate For: Demand that brands design for durability and establish clear end-of-life programs for their modal products.

  • Concrete Action Steps:

    • Champion Durability and Quality: Advocate for brands to invest in the quality of their modal fabrics, ensuring they are blended for strength and designed for longevity. On product review pages, make it a point to praise garments that have lasted for years, and conversely, call out items that have failed prematurely. This feedback directly influences design and material choices. A product developer for a clothing line could use this customer feedback to justify a higher-cost, more durable modal blend to their leadership team.

    • Push for Take-Back and Recycling Programs: Encourage brands to implement take-back programs specifically for their modal garments. While modal is biodegradable, it can also be recycled into new fibers. An advocacy group could launch a campaign with a hashtag like #ModalRecycleNow, tagging major brands and asking, “What’s the plan for my old modal t-shirt when it wears out? Do you have a recycling program for it?” This puts direct pressure on brands to create and promote circular solutions.

The Advocate’s Toolkit: Tailored Strategies for Impact

Effective advocacy requires a multi-pronged approach, targeting different stakeholders with a message tailored to their influence. Here is a breakdown of practical strategies for each type of advocate.

For the Conscious Consumer: Your Wallet is Your Voice

Your power lies in your purchasing decisions and your collective voice. Every dollar you spend and every message you send is a vote for the type of fashion industry you want to see.

  • Strategy 1: Direct Brand Engagement
    • How to Do It: Use social media, email, and customer service channels to ask specific, informed questions. Avoid generic statements like “be more sustainable.” Instead, use the knowledge from this guide.

    • Concrete Example: On a brand’s Instagram post featuring a modal garment, leave a comment: “Love this piece! Where do you source your modal from? Do you work with a certified supplier like Lenzing?” This publicly asks the question, encouraging a public response and signaling to other consumers that they should also be asking these questions.

    • Another Example: If a brand claims “eco-friendly modal,” send a direct message or email asking for the specific certifications. “Hi, I saw your claim about eco-friendly modal. Can you tell me if this is certified by OEKO-TEX or the EU Ecolabel, and if the wood pulp is FSC certified? Transparency is key for my purchasing decisions.”

  • Strategy 2: Vote with Your Dollars

    • How to Do It: Actively seek out and purchase from brands that are transparent and have a proven commitment to sustainable modal.

    • Concrete Example: If Brand A uses generic modal and Brand B prominently features TENCEL™ Modal from Lenzing with FSC certification, choose Brand B. Then, send a message to Brand B, explaining exactly why you chose them. “I just purchased your modal dress specifically because I saw you use TENCEL™ from Lenzing. I appreciate your commitment to closed-loop production and responsible forestry. Keep up the great work!” This positive reinforcement is a powerful tool.

  • Strategy 3: Community and Collective Action

    • How to Do It: Join or create online communities focused on sustainable fashion. Share your findings, research, and success stories.

    • Concrete Example: Start a thread in a sustainable fashion subreddit or Facebook group: “I just found a brand using FSC-certified modal! Let’s share some of our favorite ethical modal brands.” This helps other consumers find responsible options and creates a collective pressure on other brands to follow suit.

For the Fashion Employee: Drive Change from the Inside

You have a unique opportunity to influence decisions, from product development to marketing strategy. Your internal position gives you access and credibility that an external advocate may not have.

  • Strategy 1: The Business Case for Sustainability
    • How to Do It: Frame your advocacy in terms of business value. Connect sustainable practices to brand reputation, customer loyalty, and long-term risk mitigation.

    • Concrete Example: In a product meeting, when a team member suggests sourcing cheaper, uncertified modal, present a slide with data on consumer demand for transparency. “I’ve been tracking competitor data and seeing a significant increase in consumer inquiries about modal sourcing. Moving to a certified supplier like Lenzing not only aligns with our brand values but also mitigates the risk of a consumer backlash and allows us to command a higher price point for a premium, verified product. It’s a win-win for reputation and revenue.”

  • Strategy 2: Pilot Programs and Internal Initiatives

    • How to Do It: Propose small-scale, manageable projects that demonstrate the viability and benefits of sustainable modal.

    • Concrete Example: Suggest a pilot project for a new product line using only TENCEL™ Modal. Offer to lead the research on supplier costs and marketing messaging. Once the product launches, track customer feedback and sales data. A successful pilot can serve as a proof-of-concept to scale the initiative across the entire company.

  • Strategy 3: Educate and Empower Your Colleagues

    • How to Do It: Share your knowledge and resources with your team. Create an internal “green team” or a sustainability committee.

    • Concrete Example: Host a lunch-and-learn session on modal sustainability, using the Canopy report and TENCEL™’s resources. Distribute a one-page “Modal Sourcing Checklist” for the design and procurement teams, making it easy for them to prioritize certified and responsible suppliers.

For the Industry Professional and Policymaker: Reshaping the System

Your role is to create the large-scale systemic change that individual action alone cannot achieve. You are the architect of a more responsible industry.

  • Strategy 1: Promote and Strengthen Certifications and Standards
    • How to Do It: Work with industry bodies and certification organizations to develop and enforce more rigorous standards for modal production.

    • Concrete Example: A representative from a fashion industry trade association could join forces with the FSC and OEKO-TEX to create a new “Sustainable Modal Alliance.” This alliance would establish and promote a clear set of criteria for what constitutes a truly sustainable modal supply chain, making it easier for brands and consumers to identify ethical products.

  • Strategy 2: Advocate for Regulatory and Policy Changes

    • How to Do It: Push for government policies that incentivize sustainable practices and penalize environmental damage.

    • Concrete Example: Lobby for legislation that requires brands to be transparent about their modal sourcing and production methods. This could include a mandatory “Fiber Sourcing Disclosure” on product tags or websites, detailing the origin of the wood pulp and the chemicals used in processing. This levels the playing field and prevents greenwashing.

  • Strategy 3: Drive Innovation and Investment

    • How to Do It: Direct resources and investment towards new technologies and research that further improve modal’s sustainability.

    • Concrete Example: As an investor, prioritize textile companies and startups that are developing groundbreaking technologies for modal production, such as more efficient closed-loop systems, non-toxic solvents, or advanced textile-to-textile recycling processes. Publicly highlight these investments to signal to the market that sustainability is a key driver of future value.

Overcoming Obstacles and Maintaining Momentum

Advocacy is a marathon, not a sprint. It’s crucial to anticipate and address common roadblocks while maintaining a positive and persistent approach.

  • The “Cost” Argument: One of the most common pushbacks is that sustainable practices are too expensive. Counter this by highlighting the long-term benefits: enhanced brand reputation, increased customer loyalty, and reduced risk of environmental fines or supply chain disruptions. Frame sustainable modal as an investment, not an expense.

  • The “Lack of Transparency” Barrier: Many brands hide behind vague claims and opaque supply chains. Use the power of informed questions to demand clarity. If a brand refuses to disclose information, make that refusal public. The absence of a response is itself a powerful statement.

  • The Problem of Scale: A single advocate may feel their voice is insignificant. This is where collective action is key. Join forces with others. A single tweet might be ignored, but a thousand tweets with the same hashtag demanding transparency is a powerful force that no brand can afford to dismiss.

By understanding the key principles of sustainable modal production and leveraging these tailored advocacy strategies, we can collectively steer the fashion industry toward a more responsible and regenerative future. The tools are in our hands; the time to act is now.