How to Choose Cufflinks for a Historical Reenactment

by

The Definitive Guide to Choosing Historically Accurate Cufflinks for Reenactments

Choosing the right cufflinks for a historical reenactment is about more than just adding a finishing touch; it’s about honoring the details that bring an era to life. A single anachronistic detail can break the illusion for both the participant and the observer. This guide will walk you through the practical, actionable steps of selecting cufflinks that are not only historically accurate but also appropriate for your specific persona, social standing, and the occasion you are reenacting.

Understanding the Eras: A Timeline of Cufflink Evolution

Cufflinks, as we know them, didn’t just appear overnight. Their design, materials, and method of closure evolved dramatically over several centuries. Your first step is to pinpoint the exact era you are portraying. The difference between a Georgian-era cufflink and one from the Edwardian period is significant.

18th Century (Georgian Era, Late Colonial America)

In the 18th century, cufflinks were often referred to as “sleeve buttons.” They were a status symbol, predominantly worn by the wealthy elite and gentlemen of means. The style was generally simple yet elegant.

  • Materials: Gold, silver, and paste jewels were common. Enamel work was also popular, featuring intricate designs or small portraits.

  • Design: Look for simple, circular or oval faces. The faces were often linked by a short chain or a thin metal bar. Designs were frequently engraved with monograms, family crests, or simple patterns like sunbursts or geometric shapes.

  • Closure: The classic dumbbell shape was prevalent. Two identical faces were linked by a chain. The closure was secure but not overly complex.

  • Actionable Advice: If you are reenacting a wealthy merchant or a gentleman farmer, seek out cufflinks with a chain link and a subtle engraving. Avoid anything with a hinged post or a whaleback closure, as these are much later innovations. A good starting point would be looking for reproductions of Georgian-era paste diamond cufflinks.

19th Century (Regency, Victorian, American Civil War)

The 19th century saw a massive expansion in the use of cufflinks, moving from a strictly aristocratic accessory to a staple of the middle-class man’s wardrobe. This era is characterized by a wider variety of materials and designs.

Regency Era (Early 19th Century)

The transition from the 18th to the 19th century was marked by a slight simplification in design.

  • Materials: Gold and silver remained popular, but materials like cut steel, a highly polished form of steel that mimicked the sparkle of diamonds, became fashionable.

  • Design: Simpler designs were in vogue. Monograms and geometric patterns were still common, but the overall look was less ornate than the late Georgian period.

  • Actionable Advice: For a Regency-era dandy or a military officer, consider cut steel cufflinks. Their subtle sparkle and intricate facets are a dead giveaway for the period.

Victorian Era (Mid-to-Late 19th Century)

This was a golden age for cufflinks. The Industrial Revolution made them more affordable, and a huge variety of styles emerged.

  • Materials: The range of materials exploded. Gold, silver, and mother-of-pearl were ubiquitous. Black jet and onyx became fashionable for mourning wear. Gilded metals, semi-precious stones like agate and malachite, and even tortoiseshell were used.

  • Design: Victorian cufflinks were often more decorative than their predecessors. Cameos, carved from shell or stone, were popular. Intricate repoussé work (hammered relief designs) and filigree became common. The introduction of photography led to cufflinks with miniature portraits or tintypes enclosed in glass.

  • Closure: While the chain link remained, the hinged toggle or T-bar closure began to appear, especially later in the century.

  • Actionable Advice: For a mid-Victorian reenactor, a set of mother-of-pearl cufflinks with a simple chain link is a safe, versatile choice. If portraying a mourner, seek out cufflinks made of black jet or onyx. For a wealthy industrialist, a pair with a carved cameo or an intricate engraved design would be perfect.

American Civil War Era (1860s)

This period is a specific sub-set of the Victorian era, with its own stylistic nuances.

  • Materials: Military-issued cufflinks were often simple brass or gilded metal. Civilian cufflinks followed broader Victorian trends.

  • Design: For military portrayals, look for simple, robust cufflinks, often with a chain link. Civilian cufflinks might feature mother-of-pearl, simple engravings, or even patriotic motifs.

  • Actionable Advice: If you’re a Union or Confederate officer, a pair of brass cuff buttons is a must. For a civilian portraying a prosperous merchant, stick to mother-of-pearl or simple, non-ostentatious designs.

20th Century (Edwardian, Art Deco, Mid-Century)

The turn of the century and the decades that followed brought about major changes in design and mass production.

Edwardian Era (Early 1900s)

This period saw a continuation of Victorian trends, but with a lighter, more streamlined aesthetic.

  • Materials: Gold and silver were still dominant, but platinum became increasingly popular. Gemstones like diamonds and sapphires were often used.

  • Design: The designs were a mix of traditional and modern. Art Nouveau influenced some cufflinks with their flowing, organic lines. Enamel work was refined, often featuring intricate guilloché patterns.

  • Closure: The hinged post closure, which is the most common style today, became the standard.

  • Actionable Advice: A great choice for an Edwardian reenactment is a pair of silver cufflinks with a simple T-bar closure and a subtle engine-turned or engraved pattern. Enamel cufflinks with a guilloché pattern are also a perfect, period-appropriate option.

Art Deco (1920s-1930s)

Art Deco cufflinks are a distinct departure from previous styles, reflecting the geometric and streamlined aesthetic of the age.

  • Materials: Platinum, gold, and chrome were popular. Enamel in bold colors was a hallmark of the style.

  • Design: Look for clean lines, geometric shapes (squares, rectangles, octagons), and bold, contrasting colors. Mother-of-pearl and onyx were often set in intricate patterns.

  • Closure: The hinged post and whaleback closures were the norm.

  • Actionable Advice: For a 1920s portrayal, seek out cufflinks with a rectangular or octagonal face, often with black onyx or mother-of-pearl and a geometric pattern. The T-bar closure is a must.

Persona and Social Standing: The Subtleties of Cufflink Choice

Your character’s social status, occupation, and financial situation are as important as the era itself. A factory worker would not be wearing the same cufflinks as a banking heir.

The Working Class and Everyday Man

For a portrayal of a working-class individual, farmer, or a soldier in the ranks, cufflinks are generally inappropriate. Shirts worn by these individuals often had simple button closures or were tied at the cuff with a simple ribbon or string.

  • Actionable Advice: Don’t wear cufflinks. Period. If you are portraying a soldier, check the regulations and historical examples for your specific unit. Most rank-and-file soldiers did not wear cufflinks.

The Middle Class and Skilled Tradesmen

As the 19th century progressed, the middle class grew and adopted accessories that were once exclusive to the elite. A middle-class man would own a pair of cufflinks, but they would be understated.

  • Materials: Gilded metal, brass, mother-of-pearl, and simple silver were common. Anything overtly flashy would be out of place.

  • Design: Simple, unadorned designs. A plain mother-of-pearl face, a simple engraved monogram, or a single initial would be a solid choice.

  • Actionable Advice: A pair of plain mother-of-pearl cufflinks with a chain link is the perfect choice for a Victorian shopkeeper or a skilled tradesman. It shows he is a man of means, but not a man of great wealth.

The Upper Class and Aristocracy

Here is where you can be a bit more flamboyant with your choices, within the context of the era.

  • Materials: Solid gold, silver, and precious stones were the standard. Engraved family crests, intricate enamel work, and a higher level of craftsmanship were expected.

  • Design: Anything from a simple, elegant design to an elaborate cameo or miniature portrait. The level of detail and quality of the materials is the key differentiator.

  • Actionable Advice: For a late-19th-century gentleman of leisure, a pair of cufflinks with a small diamond or a sapphire set in gold would be appropriate. For an Edwardian aristocrat, a pair with a beautifully enameled guilloché pattern would be spot on.

The Reenactment’s Context: Choosing Cufflinks for the Occasion

The type of event you are attending also dictates your choice. A casual day at a living history museum is different from a formal ball or a military campaign event.

Formal Events (Balls, Dinners, Grand Events)

For a formal event, you need to step up your cufflink game. The focus is on elegance and luxury.

  • Actionable Advice: For a formal Victorian event, a pair of ornate gold or silver cufflinks with intricate engraving or a semi-precious stone would be appropriate. For an Edwardian ball, a pair of platinum cufflinks with a small diamond or a set of mother-of-pearl cufflinks in a formal setting is an excellent choice.

Everyday and Casual Portrayals

For day-to-day life at a living history event, your cufflinks should be practical and understated.

  • Actionable Advice: A simple, solid silver or mother-of-pearl cufflink will work for almost any period from the mid-19th to early 20th centuries. It’s a versatile choice that won’t distract from the rest of your outfit.

Military Reenactments

Military reenactments have their own set of rules. The uniform and its accessories are often dictated by regulations.

  • Actionable Advice: For a Civil War officer, your cufflinks should be simple and functional, likely brass or gilded metal. For a WWI officer, the cufflink would likely be a simple, gold or silver design, but a careful examination of military regulations for the specific army and rank is essential.

Practical Shopping and Selection Tips

Now that you understand the historical context, here’s how to put that knowledge into practice.

Where to Look for Authentic Cufflinks

  • Reputable Reenactment Suppliers: Many specialized vendors create historically accurate reproductions. They often have done the research for you. Look for suppliers who detail the history of their products.

  • Antique and Vintage Stores: This is the best way to find truly authentic pieces. Be prepared to pay a higher price and be vigilant about identifying fakes. Look for hallmarks and maker’s marks, and be sure to check the closure style.

  • Online Marketplaces (with caution): Websites like Etsy and eBay can be goldmines, but they can also be filled with fakes and misidentified items. Only purchase from sellers with good reviews who provide detailed photos and are knowledgeable about their products.

What to Look For: A Checklist

  • Closure Type: Is it a chain link, a T-bar, or a hinged post? The closure is often the easiest way to date a cufflink. A chain link is a safe bet for earlier eras, while a hinged post is a post-1900 innovation.

  • Materials: Does the material match the era and your persona? Avoid modern plastics or alloys.

  • Design: Is the design appropriate for the period? Are there any anachronistic elements? For example, a modern, highly polished, minimalist design would be completely out of place in a Victorian setting.

  • Condition: If you are buying an antique, is it in good enough condition to be worn? Are the closures functional?

  • The “Feel”: Does it feel right? Does the weight, construction, and overall aesthetic feel like something a person from that era would have worn?

The Flawless Finish: Final Considerations

Your cufflink choice is a reflection of your commitment to authenticity. The smallest detail can make the biggest difference in a reenactment.

  • Consistency is Key: Your cufflinks should match your character’s overall look. Don’t wear a luxurious pair of gold cufflinks with a coarse linen shirt.

  • Comfort: Reenactments can be long and physically demanding. Make sure the cufflinks you choose are comfortable to wear and won’t catch on your clothes or cause irritation.

  • Avoid the “Costume” Look: The goal is to look like you stepped out of a historical photograph, not a Hollywood costume department. Avoid anything that looks cheap, flashy, or overly theatrical. Authenticity lies in the subtleties.

In the end, choosing the right cufflinks for your historical reenactment is a journey of research and careful consideration. It’s an opportunity to delve into the material culture of a specific time and place. By paying attention to the era, your persona, and the context of the event, you will select a piece that not only completes your outfit but also enriches your entire reenactment experience.