How to Choose the Best Buttons and Closures for Your Knitted Fashion

by

Choosing the perfect buttons and closures for your knitted garments is the final, crucial step that elevates a handmade item from a simple craft project to a professional, finished piece of fashion. The right choice can define the aesthetic, improve the functionality, and ensure the longevity of your hard work. This guide will walk you through the essential considerations, from material and size to style and technique, providing you with a clear, actionable framework to make the best decisions for every project.

Understanding the Role of Buttons and Closures

Before we dive into the specifics, let’s appreciate what these small details accomplish. A button isn’t just a fastener; it’s an accessory. It can be a subtle accent that complements your yarn, a bold statement piece that defines the garment’s character, or a functional element that makes a heavy sweater wearable. Closures, too, range from simple toggles to intricate zippers, each serving a unique purpose and contributing to the overall design. Your goal is to find a balance between form and function, ensuring your choice enhances, not detracts from, your beautiful knitting.

The Foundation: Analyzing Your Garment

Your first step is to thoroughly analyze the knitted item itself. This analysis will dictate the most practical and aesthetically pleasing choices.

1. Garment Weight and Gauge

This is the single most important factor. A heavy, bulky sweater requires different closures than a delicate lace shawl.

  • Heavyweight/Bulky Knits: Think chunky cardigans, blanket coats, and rugged vests. These require substantial closures that can withstand the weight and tension.
    • Buttons: Opt for large, thick buttons made of durable materials like wood, horn, or metal. A 1-inch diameter is a good starting point, but you can go even larger. The buttonholes themselves must be stable and reinforced to prevent stretching and gapping.

    • Closures: Toggles are an excellent choice for a rustic, heavy look. Large hook-and-eye sets or even a sturdy, chunky zipper can also work. Avoid small, delicate buttons that will be overwhelmed and potentially pull through the fabric.

  • Medium-Weight Knits: This includes most standard sweaters, cardigans, and vests using worsted or DK weight yarn. You have the most flexibility here.

    • Buttons: A wide range of materials and sizes (1/2 inch to 3/4 inch) are suitable. Consider classic shell buttons for a sophisticated touch, or resin buttons for a pop of color. The buttonholes should be snug but not so tight that they distort the knit.

    • Closures: Standard zippers work well, as do snap closures for a modern, minimalist look.

  • Lightweight/Lace Knits: These are delicate items like fine gauge cardigans, shawls, and baby sweaters. The closures must be light and discreet.

    • Buttons: Small, lightweight buttons are essential. Mother-of-pearl, tiny glass buttons, or small metal shank buttons are perfect. A 3/8-inch to 1/2-inch size is usually ideal. Avoid heavy buttons that will drag and stretch the fabric.

    • Closures: For very delicate items, a simple tie-front closure using a knitted i-cord or ribbon can be a beautiful solution. Small, discreet hook-and-eyes or tiny snaps are also viable options for keeping the front closed without a bulky button.

2. Garment Style and Aesthetic

The style of your garment should guide the aesthetic of your closures. A rustic, hand-spun wool sweater calls for a different button than a sleek, modern cardigan.

  • Rustic/Bohemian: Think natural materials. Wood buttons with visible grain, horn buttons with unique markings, or leather toggles.

  • Classic/Preppy: Go for timeless options. Pearlized shell buttons, simple polished metal buttons, or small, classic resin buttons in a neutral color.

  • Modern/Minimalist: Consider hidden closures. Snaps, magnetic clasps, or a sleek, color-matched zipper. If you use buttons, choose flat, unadorned ones in a monochrome palette.

  • Vintage/Feminine: Look for ornate or unique buttons. Glass buttons, faceted acrylic, or buttons with intricate metal detailing. You can also find vintage buttons from antique shops for a truly unique touch.

3. Color and Texture

The color and texture of your yarn are paramount. Your closure can either blend in or stand out.

  • Blending In: For a seamless, sophisticated look, choose buttons that are a slightly darker or lighter shade of your yarn color. This creates a cohesive, monochrome effect.

  • Making a Statement: To draw attention to the closure, choose a contrasting color. If your sweater is a neutral gray, a row of bright red buttons can add a vibrant and unexpected pop.

  • Complementing Texture: If your yarn has a unique texture (e.g., tweed, bouclĂ©, or mohair), choose a closure that complements it. A tweed yarn pairs well with a natural, earthy button. A smooth, sleek yarn can handle a shiny metal or glass button.

A Deep Dive into Button Types

Buttons are not a one-size-fits-all category. Understanding the different types will help you choose the most functional and appropriate option.

1. Shank Buttons vs. Two-Hole/Four-Hole Buttons

This is a fundamental distinction that affects both the aesthetic and the durability of the closure.

  • Shank Buttons: These buttons have a loop or shank on the back through which you sew.
    • Pros: They sit slightly above the fabric, allowing for a thicker seam or buttonhole. This is especially useful for bulky knits where a flat button might be too tight. The shank also prevents the button from pulling the fabric taut when closed, which can cause gapping. They offer a cleaner, more streamlined look on the front.

    • Cons: They can be slightly more difficult to sew on and may wobble more if the shank is too long or the button is too heavy for the fabric.

    • Best For: Bulky knits, heavy cardigans, and jackets where a bit of space is needed between the button and the buttonhole band.

  • Two-Hole/Four-Hole Buttons: These are the traditional flat buttons you sew directly through the holes.

    • Pros: Very easy to sew on, and they lie flat against the fabric. You can reinforce the attachment by sewing through all four holes in a cross or parallel pattern.

    • Cons: On a thick garment, the button can be pulled tight against the fabric, making it difficult to button and potentially distorting the knit. To avoid this, you must create a thread shank (a small loop of thread under the button) when sewing.

    • Best For: Lightweight to medium-weight knits where a flat profile is desired.

2. Button Materials

The material of your button influences its weight, durability, and aesthetic.

  • Wood: Natural, earthy, and lightweight. Great for rustic or bohemian projects. The grain and color variations can add a unique touch. Ensure the button is smooth and finished to prevent snagging your yarn.

  • Horn: A luxurious and sophisticated choice. Each button is unique due to the natural variations in the horn. It has a beautiful weight and sheen. Excellent for classic, high-end knits.

  • Coconut Shell: An eco-friendly and lightweight option with a beautiful, textured surface. Perfect for casual, summery knits.

  • Mother-of-Pearl/Shell: A timeless and elegant choice. They have a luminous quality and are perfect for delicate, fine-gauge knits. Be careful, as they can be brittle and may chip if not handled gently.

  • Metal: Can range from polished and sleek to antique and rustic. Metal buttons add weight and a distinct feel. Ensure the edges are smooth to avoid snagging. A great choice for blazers or structured cardigans.

  • Resin/Plastic: The most common and versatile option. Available in a vast array of colors, sizes, and shapes. Lightweight and durable, they are a practical choice for almost any project.

  • Leather: Often used for toggles, leather provides a rugged, natural look. Paired with a corresponding loop, it’s perfect for heavy coats or cardigans.

Navigating Other Closure Options

Buttons aren’t the only game in town. Other closures can provide different levels of functionality and aesthetic appeal.

1. Zippers

Zippers offer a clean, continuous closure that is perfect for modern, streamlined garments.

  • Choosing the Right Zipper: The weight of the zipper must match the weight of your garment. A heavy-duty metal zipper is for a chunky sweater, while a lightweight nylon zipper is for a fine-gauge knit.

  • Installation: Zippers in knitting require careful installation. You can either sew the zipper directly to the knitted fabric or, for a more professional finish, pick up stitches along the front opening and knit a small facing to which the zipper is attached. This provides a stable, non-stretching surface.

2. Snaps and Magnetic Clasps

These closures provide a fast, secure, and often invisible fastening.

  • Snaps: Perfect for minimalist garments or baby clothes where traditional buttons might be a choking hazard. Choose a snap size that corresponds to your knit’s weight. You can sew them on directly or, for extra stability, sew them onto a small piece of ribbon or grosgrain and then attach that strip to the garment.

  • Magnetic Clasps: These are a contemporary, high-end option. They provide a strong, effortless closure. They are ideal for jackets or bags where you want a clean exterior without visible buttons. Sew them onto a reinforced patch of fabric on the inside of the garment to prevent them from pulling through the knit.

3. Toggles and Clasps

These are statement closures that are integral to the garment’s design.

  • Toggles: A toggle consists of a piece of wood, horn, or plastic and a loop to hold it. They have a rustic, nautical, or academic feel. Perfect for chunky knits and duffle coats. The loop can be a simple i-cord, a knitted strap, or a piece of leather or ribbon.

  • Clasps: These can be intricate metal or plastic closures. They often have a vintage or medieval feel. They work well on heavier garments or for a very specific stylistic choice. Ensure the clasp is securely attached to a reinforced piece of fabric to withstand repeated use.

Practical Application: A Step-by-Step Approach

Now let’s synthesize these concepts into a practical, step-by-step process.

Step 1: The Design Review. Look at your finished (or almost finished) garment. Hold it up and think about the overall impression you want to make. Is it a cozy, rustic piece or a sleek, elegant one?

Step 2: The Weight Test. Feel the weight and drape of the fabric. Is it heavy and stiff, or light and airy? This will immediately narrow down your choices for size and material. Don’t put a heavy button on a light garment, or a tiny button on a chunky knit.

Step 3: The Color & Style Harmony. Gather a selection of potential closures. Place them on the garment. Don’t be afraid to try contrasting colors. Hold the garment up at arm’s length. Does the closure blend in beautifully or stand out in a good way? For a classic look, match the buttons to the yarn color. For a bold statement, choose a contrasting hue or material.

Step 4: The Functionality Check. Imagine yourself buttoning and unbuttoning the garment. Is the button a good size for the buttonhole? Can you easily manipulate the toggle? Is the zipper smooth? This step is crucial for ensuring your finished piece is not only beautiful but also practical.

Step 5: The Test-Knit. Before you commit to a full set of buttons, if you are unsure, sew a single button onto a swatch of your yarn. See how it looks, how it feels, and how it holds up. This is a low-risk way to confirm your decision before sewing on all of them.

Final Touches and Pro-Tips

  • Reinforce Your Buttonholes: For any knitted garment with buttonholes, especially if it’s a heavy sweater, consider reinforcing the buttonhole edge with a small amount of fabric glue or by a whip stitch to prevent stretching over time.

  • Secure Your Thread: When sewing on a button, always use a strong thread and double it up for extra durability. Knot your thread securely on the inside of the garment. For shank buttons, thread the needle through the shank multiple times. For flat buttons, use a sturdy cross-stitch pattern.

  • The Spare Button: Always save a spare button or closure. It’s a lifesaver if one gets lost or broken.

  • Consider the Entire Palette: Think about your finished garment as a whole. Do the buttons complement the yarn color, the overall style, and the eventual wearer’s personal style?

By following this guide, you will move beyond simply attaching a closure and begin to truly design and complete your knitted garments with confidence and flair. The right buttons and closures are the finishing flourish that will make your work feel truly special, professional, and ready to be worn and cherished.