How to Choose the Best Tulle for Petticoats and Underskirts

by

Choosing the perfect tulle for petticoats and underskirts is a crucial step for achieving the desired silhouette, drape, and comfort for any garment. This guide cuts through the confusion, offering a clear, actionable roadmap to selecting the ideal material for your specific project. Whether you’re a seasoned seamstress or a DIY beginner, these principles will help you make an informed decision, ensuring your creation is a success from the inside out.

Understanding the Tulle Landscape: Beyond the Basics

Before diving into the selection process, it’s essential to understand the primary types of tulle and their fundamental characteristics. The term “tulle” itself is a broad category, encompassing a wide range of materials with different fiber content, weave, and finishing. Knowing these distinctions is the first step toward making a smart choice.

  • Nylon Tulle: The most common and widely available type. Known for its affordability, durability, and a moderate stiffness. It holds its shape well, making it a great all-around choice for a variety of projects. However, it can sometimes feel slightly scratchy against the skin.

  • Polyester Tulle: Similar to nylon in its feel and function, but often a bit softer and less stiff. It’s also very durable and holds up well to washing. It’s a good alternative if you find nylon too stiff.

  • Silk Tulle (or Silk Illusion): The gold standard for luxury and comfort. It’s incredibly soft, lightweight, and drapes beautifully. Unlike its synthetic counterparts, silk tulle has a subtle sheen and is much less prone to static cling. It’s significantly more expensive, but worth the investment for high-end garments.

  • Hexagonal Netting (or Bridal Illusion): A specific type of netting with a honeycomb pattern. It’s typically made from nylon and is softer and more flexible than standard stiff tulle. This is a popular choice for wedding veils and underskirts that need a softer, more fluid shape.

  • English Net: A type of cotton netting with a hexagonal weave. It’s heavier than silk tulle, with a beautiful drape and a matte finish. It’s excellent for creating a full yet natural-looking underskirt. It’s a very high-quality and durable option.

  • Crinoline: This is not technically a tulle, but it’s often used interchangeably in the context of creating fullness. Crinoline is a stiff, open-weave fabric, often made from horsehair or synthetic fibers. It’s used for extreme structure and volume, particularly in historical costumes and formal wear.

Step 1: Define Your Desired Silhouette and Volume

This is the most critical step in the selection process. The type of tulle you choose directly dictates the shape and volume of your finished garment. Don’t just think “full”; think about the specific kind of fullness you want to achieve.

  • For a Gentle Flare and Soft Volume: Opt for a softer, more flexible tulle. A single layer of hexagonal netting or a few layers of soft polyester tulle will create a subtle lift without a rigid, “bell” shape. This is perfect for A-line skirts, retro-inspired circle skirts, or dresses where you want a natural, flowing look.
    • Concrete Example: If you’re making a 1950s-style day dress and want a gentle, non-aggressive flare, choose two layers of soft polyester tulle. It will give the skirt enough body to hold its shape without looking like a costume.
  • For a Pronounced, Structured Bell Shape: You’ll need a stiffer, more structured tulle. Multiple layers of stiff nylon tulle or a few layers of crinoline are ideal. This is the go-to for rockabilly petticoats, historical costumes, and ball gowns that require a dramatic, defined silhouette.
    • Concrete Example: To create a classic rockabilly petticoat with a sharp, outward flare, use six to eight layers of stiff nylon tulle. The stiffness of the tulle will ensure the skirt maintains its iconic bell shape.
  • For a Fluffy, “Cloud-Like” Fullness: A medium-stiff tulle with a fine, close mesh is the best choice. This creates a more rounded, less structured fullness. Layering multiple tiers of a medium-stiff nylon tulle will achieve this effect, giving a romantic and soft look.
    • Concrete Example: For a tutu or a very full ballet-style underskirt, use several layers of a medium-stiff nylon tulle. The layers will create a fluffy, ethereal look rather than a rigid structure.
  • For a High-End, Luxurious Drape: Silk tulle is the ultimate choice. It provides fullness without bulk and drapes beautifully, moving with the wearer rather than standing out stiffly. This is reserved for couture garments and special occasion wear where comfort and quality are paramount.
    • Concrete Example: When crafting an underskirt for a high-end silk chiffon evening gown, use a single layer of silk tulle. It will provide the necessary lift without adding bulk or stiffness, ensuring the outer fabric drapes perfectly.

Step 2: Consider Comfort and Wearability

A petticoat or underskirt is a foundation garment, and its comfort is just as important as its aesthetic. An itchy, scratchy underskirt can ruin the experience of wearing a beautiful dress.

  • Direct Skin Contact: If the petticoat will be worn directly against the skin, choose a soft, non-irritating material. Silk tulle, soft polyester tulle, or English net are excellent choices. Avoid stiff nylon tulle unless you are planning to add a separate soft lining.
    • Concrete Example: For a vintage-style petticoat that will be worn under a full skirt, choose soft polyester tulle or hexagonal netting. To prevent itching, either line the waistband and upper portion with a soft fabric like cotton batiste or ensure all tulle edges are encased in bias tape.
  • Layering and Linings: If you need the stiffness of nylon tulle but want the comfort of a softer material, layer it. Create a petticoat with a soft fabric lining (like cotton or satin) and then attach the stiff tulle layers to the outer shell. This provides the structure you need without sacrificing comfort.
    • Concrete Example: To make a crinoline-style petticoat for a wedding dress, construct the main body from a soft satin or cotton. Then, attach multiple layers of stiff nylon tulle to the exterior of the lining, so the stiff material never touches the skin.
  • Breathability: For garments that will be worn in warm weather or for long periods, consider the breathability of the material. Natural fibers like silk and cotton (English net) are more breathable than synthetics like nylon and polyester. This can prevent overheating and discomfort.
    • Concrete Example: If you are creating a full-skirted summer dress, an underskirt made from English net will provide a natural drape and structure while being much more breathable and comfortable than a synthetic alternative.

Step 3: Analyze the Weight and Drape of the Outer Fabric

The weight and drape of your outer fabric play a crucial role in determining the type of tulle you need. A heavy fabric requires a stronger, stiffer tulle to support it, while a lightweight fabric can be overwhelmed by an overly stiff underskirt.

  • For Heavy Fabrics (e.g., Brocade, Velvet, Heavy Cotton): You need a tulle with substantial body and stiffness to hold up the weight of the fabric. Multiple layers of stiff nylon tulle or crinoline are necessary to prevent the skirt from collapsing. A soft tulle would be completely ineffective.
    • Concrete Example: If you are making a full ball gown from a heavy velvet, use several layers of crinoline or a combination of stiff nylon tulle and crinoline. This will provide the robust support needed to hold the weight of the fabric and maintain the desired silhouette.
  • For Medium-Weight Fabrics (e.g., Poplin, Linen, Dupioni Silk): A medium-stiffness tulle is usually the best choice. It provides enough lift to showcase the fabric without making the skirt look unnaturally stiff. A few layers of medium-stiff nylon or polyester tulle will work well.
    • Concrete Example: When creating a petticoat for a circle skirt made from a medium-weight poplin, three to four layers of medium-stiff nylon tulle will give it a nice, bouncy fullness without making the skirt look stiff or unnatural.
  • For Lightweight Fabrics (e.g., Chiffon, Georgette, Fine Silk): A soft, lightweight tulle is essential. A stiff tulle would completely overpower the delicate fabric, creating a look that is jarring and unbalanced. Silk tulle or a single layer of soft polyester tulle is the best option.
    • Concrete Example: For an evening dress made from a fine silk georgette, an underskirt of soft silk tulle is the only choice. It will provide a subtle lift and prevent the delicate fabric from clinging, all while maintaining the elegant drape.

Step 4: Practical Considerations: Cost, Availability, and Durability

While aesthetics and comfort are primary, practical factors should also guide your decision. The best tulle is one you can actually afford and work with.

  • Budget-Friendly Options: Nylon and polyester tulle are the most affordable and widely available options. They come in a vast range of colors and are easy to find at most fabric stores. This is the perfect starting point for beginners or for projects where cost is a major factor.
    • Concrete Example: For a DIY rockabilly petticoat for a themed party, buying multiple yards of stiff nylon tulle is the most cost-effective and practical solution. It will provide the necessary volume without a significant financial investment.
  • Durability and Longevity: Tulle is delicate, but some types are more durable than others. Nylon and polyester are very durable and can withstand multiple washes and wears. Silk tulle is beautiful but more fragile and requires careful handling and cleaning. English net is a very durable natural fiber option.
    • Concrete Example: If you are making a petticoat for a child’s costume that will see a lot of use and machine washing, choose nylon or polyester tulle. These materials are much more forgiving and will hold up better over time than a delicate silk tulle.
  • Ease of Sewing: The stiffness of tulle can affect how easy it is to sew. Stiff tulle can be a bit challenging to manage on a sewing machine, requiring careful pinning and a steady hand. Softer tulles, while easier to sew, can be very slippery and require a walking foot or careful handling to prevent puckering.
    • Concrete Example: If you are a beginner, start with a medium-stiff polyester tulle. It has enough body to be manageable but isn’t so stiff that it’s difficult to feed through the machine. It strikes a good balance for learning the techniques.

Step 5: Tiers vs. Full Panels

The way you construct your petticoat or underskirt is just as important as the material. The two main construction methods are full panels and tiered ruffles. Each creates a different effect.

  • Full Panels: Cutting your tulle into large, full circles or panels (like a circle skirt) creates a smooth, continuous silhouette. This method is best for achieving a subtle, elegant fullness that is evenly distributed. It works best with softer tulles.
    • Concrete Example: To create a bridal underskirt that provides a smooth, elegant shape without visible seams or ruffles, use two or three full-circle panels of soft polyester tulle.
  • Tiered Ruffles: This method involves gathering strips of tulle and sewing them in tiers. It’s the most common way to create extreme volume and a “fluffy” look. The number of tiers and the amount of gathering directly correlate with the final volume. This method works well with stiff and medium-stiff tulles.
    • Concrete Example: To make a classic rockabilly petticoat with a tiered, ruffled look, cut multiple strips of stiff nylon tulle, gather them heavily, and sew them to a base layer in staggered tiers. The more strips and the heavier the gathering, the more volume you will achieve.
  • Combination Method: For a structured base with a soft top layer, you can combine methods. Use tiered stiff tulle for the main volume and then add a single, ungathered panel of a soft tulle on top to create a smooth, comfortable layer against the outer fabric.
    • Concrete Example: To create a full, comfortable petticoat for a dress, first create a tiered petticoat from stiff nylon tulle. Then, sew a single, full panel of soft polyester tulle or hexagonal netting over the top tier. This provides a soft, smooth outer surface.

Conclusion

Selecting the right tulle is not an art, but a series of informed decisions based on your specific project needs. By systematically considering the desired silhouette, comfort, the outer fabric’s weight, and practical factors like cost and durability, you can make a choice that will elevate your garment from good to exceptional. The principles outlined here provide a clear, actionable framework, empowering you to confidently choose the best tulle every time and ensure your petticoat or underskirt is the perfect foundation for your masterpiece.