Choosing the perfect collar for a bespoke shirt is a nuanced art form. It’s the single most defining feature of a shirt, framing your face, influencing your silhouette, and communicating a specific style. This is a guide to mastering that art, moving beyond basic choices to a truly personalized selection. We will delve into the details that transform a good shirt into a great one.
The Foundation: Your Face Shape and Proportions
Before you even consider style, the first rule of collar selection is to balance your own physical attributes. The right collar will complement your face, not fight it.
Round Faces: A round face benefits from collars that add vertical lines and length. The goal is to elongate the neck and create a more angular appearance.
- Recommendation: A classic point collar is an excellent choice. Its narrow spread and long points draw the eye downwards. A tab collar also works well by lifting the tie knot and creating a vertical line.
-
What to Avoid: Stay away from wide spread collars like the cutaway or Italian spread. These collars echo the roundness of your face and can make it appear wider.
Oval Faces: The oval face is the most versatile and can pull off almost any collar style. This freedom allows you to focus more on the shirt’s function and your personal style.
- Recommendation: Experiment with everything. A semi-spread is a great daily driver. For a more formal look, a classic point or a club collar works beautifully.
-
What to Avoid: Nothing is strictly off-limits, but be mindful of proportion. An extremely narrow point collar might look diminutive on a larger oval face, while a tiny club collar might get lost.
Square Faces: Strong, angular jawlines are the hallmark of a square face. The best collars will soften these angles slightly or at least not exaggerate them.
- Recommendation: A semi-spread or a moderate spread collar works well. The wider angle of the collar points helps to balance the width of the jawline. A cutaway collar can also be a bold choice, as its extreme spread contrasts with the strong horizontal line of the jaw.
-
What to Avoid: A very narrow point collar can look severe and accentuate the squareness.
Long/Rectangular Faces: The goal here is to add width and horizontal lines to shorten the appearance of the face.
- Recommendation: Wide spread collars are your best friend. The cutaway, Italian, and spread collars all work to broaden the look of the neck and jawline. A club collar with its rounded points can also soften the long lines.
-
What to Avoid: Point collars or any collar with a narrow spread will only make a long face appear even longer.
Neck Length: A long neck can be balanced with a shorter collar band and a wider spread. A shorter neck is best suited to a lower collar band height to avoid a “choked” appearance, and a point or semi-spread collar.
Decoding the Anatomy of the Collar
A bespoke shirt collar is not a monolithic piece of fabric. It’s a construction of several components, each of which can be customized to change the look, feel, and function. Understanding these parts is key to making informed decisions.
1. Collar Band Height: This is the height of the fabric that goes around your neck.
- Standard: A typical collar band height is around 1 to 1.5 inches.
-
Customization: A taller collar band (1.75+ inches) adds formality and a more architectural feel. It’s excellent for making a statement with a tie. A lower collar band (less than 1 inch) is more casual and comfortable, often seen on sport shirts or casual button-downs.
-
Practical Example: For a business suit, a 1.75-inch collar band gives the shirt a robust presence under the jacket lapels. For a casual linen shirt, a 1-inch band provides a relaxed, open feel.
2. Collar Point Length: This is the length from where the collar folds down to the tip of the collar point.
- Standard: Typically ranges from 3 to 3.5 inches.
-
Customization: Longer points (4+ inches) create a more traditional, vintage look, often seen on classic banker shirts. Shorter points (less than 3 inches) are more modern and casual.
-
Practical Example: A 4-inch collar point on a starched white shirt is perfect for a power business suit. A 2.5-inch collar point on a printed casual shirt feels contemporary and clean.
3. Collar Spread: This is the distance between the two collar points. This is arguably the most important variable in defining the collar’s character.
- Point Collar: The narrowest spread, typically around 2-3 inches. It creates a formal, conservative look and is excellent for classic ties and tie knots.
-
Semi-Spread (or English Spread): A versatile middle ground with a spread of 4-5 inches. It accommodates most tie knots and is the default for many modern business shirts.
-
Cutaway Collar (or Extreme Spread): The widest spread, with the points cut at an almost horizontal angle. It’s a high-fashion, modern choice that works well for larger tie knots like the Windsor. It can also be worn open for a distinctive look.
-
Club Collar (or Eton Collar): Features rounded collar points and a narrow spread. It’s a retro, preppy style that is making a comeback. It’s less formal than a point collar but has a distinct character.
-
Button-Down Collar: The collar points are fastened to the shirt body with a button. It’s an American classic, originally for polo players, and is inherently more casual.
-
Wing Collar: Reserved exclusively for black or white tie events. The tips of the collar stand up and fold over, creating “wings” to hold the bow tie.
4. Interlining and Stiffness: This refers to the layer of fabric between the two layers of the collar, which provides structure and stiffness.
- Fusing: A stiff, synthetic material that is heat-pressed to the collar fabric. It results in a crisp, sharp collar that holds its shape impeccably, even after many washes. This is the standard for most formal and business shirts.
-
Unfused (or Soft): No interlining or a very light, non-fused interlining. This results in a soft, rolling collar that is much more casual and comfortable. This is ideal for linen, flannel, or chambray shirts.
-
Example: For a classic business shirt, a fused collar with a moderate spread is a must. For a weekend shirt, an unfused button-down or club collar provides a relaxed, effortless style.
Tying It All Together: Function and Form
The ultimate decision rests on the shirt’s intended purpose and the ties you plan to wear with it. The collar and tie must work in harmony.
Business and Formal Wear:
- The Go-To: A semi-spread collar is the most reliable choice. It’s versatile enough for a variety of tie knots and looks sharp both with and without a jacket.
-
Actionable Advice: If you favor a smaller, four-in-hand tie knot, a point collar will frame it perfectly without a lot of open space. If you prefer a larger Windsor knot, a spread collar is essential to accommodate the bulk and maintain balance.
-
Concrete Example: A crisp white pinpoint oxford with a semi-spread collar, paired with a navy silk tie, is the quintessential business uniform.
Casual and Everyday Wear:
- The Go-To: Button-down collars are the undisputed kings of casual elegance. They look great with or without a tie, under a blazer, or on their own.
-
Actionable Advice: Consider an unfused collar for a relaxed, natural roll. A club collar also adds a touch of vintage cool to a casual outfit. For a truly minimalist look, a band collar (or grandad collar) is a perfect choice, offering a clean line without a tie.
-
Concrete Example: A light blue chambray shirt with a soft, unfused button-down collar and the sleeves rolled up is the perfect weekend look.
Evening and Special Occasions:
- The Go-To: For a tuxedo, a wing collar is the only option, specifically designed to hold a bow tie. For a sophisticated dinner jacket, a dress shirt with a semi-spread or a cutaway collar is appropriate, again paired with a bow tie.
-
Actionable Advice: The shirt should be made from a formal fabric like pique, poplin, or silk. The collar should be stiff and well-starched to stand up to the gravitas of the occasion.
-
Concrete Example: A crisp white piqué shirt with a wing collar, paired with a black silk bow tie and tuxedo, is the benchmark for formal attire.
Beyond the Basics: Advanced Collar Considerations
For the true connoisseur, the details matter.
The Collar Roll: This is a term specifically for button-down collars. A good “roll” is the gentle, S-shaped curve of the collar from the neckband to the button. It’s a sign of a well-made shirt with a good collar stand and point length. A high-quality unfused button-down collar with a long point will have a natural, elegant roll.
Hidden Collar Stays: These are small, removable plastic or metal pieces inserted into pockets on the underside of the collar points. They keep the collar points from curling or flopping.
- Actionable Advice: Always choose shirts with removable collar stays, as this allows you to remove them before washing and replace them with higher-quality metal stays if desired. A stiff, fused collar should always have stays. A soft, unfused collar is designed to be stay-less.
Collar Gaping: This occurs when the collar pulls away from the neck. It can be due to a collar that is too small or a poor cut.
- Actionable Advice: When getting fitted for a bespoke shirt, ensure the collar size allows for a comfortable fit with one finger between your neck and the collar. A well-cut collar should sit flush against your neck without any gaps.
The Collar’s Relationship to the Jacket: The collar must fit correctly under the lapels of a suit jacket. A well-proportioned collar should peek out just enough—about half an inch—above the jacket’s collar. A collar that is too low will be swallowed by the jacket, while one that is too high will look awkward.
The Ultimate Checklist for Bespoke Collar Selection
- Face Shape & Neck Length: Match the collar’s spread and point length to your facial structure.
- Round: Narrow point collar.
-
Square/Long: Wider spread collar.
-
Oval: Versatile.
-
Function & Form: Determine the primary use of the shirt (business, casual, formal).
- Business: Semi-spread, Point collar.
-
Casual: Button-down, Club collar, Unfused.
-
Formal: Wing collar, stiff semi-spread.
-
Tie and Tie Knot: Consider the size and style of your preferred tie knot.
- Small knot: Point collar.
-
Large knot: Wide spread collar.
-
Bow tie: Wing collar or semi-spread.
-
Collar Band Height: Choose a height that complements your neck length and the formality of the shirt.
- Long Neck: Taller band.
-
Short Neck: Shorter band.
-
Interlining & Stiffness: Decide whether you want a crisp, structured collar or a soft, natural one.
- Business: Fused, stiff.
-
Casual: Unfused, soft.
-
Collar Stays: Ensure your choice of collar has the right kind of support for its intended stiffness.
-
Proportion: Think about how the collar will look with a jacket, its points not extending past the lapels.
-
Personal Style: After all the rules, the final choice is a reflection of you. Choose a collar that makes you feel confident and authentic.
A Powerful Conclusion
The collar is the soul of a bespoke shirt. It’s a small detail that makes a profound statement about your style, your attention to detail, and your understanding of classic menswear principles. By methodically considering your own physical attributes, the shirt’s purpose, and the anatomy of the collar itself, you move beyond simply selecting a style and begin to craft a true expression of your personal brand. The perfect collar isn’t just about looking good; it’s about feeling perfectly put together, confident, and ready for any occasion.