A Definitive Guide to Choosing the Right Buttons for Your Frock Coat
The frock coat, a sartorial powerhouse, commands respect and exudes an air of refined elegance. Yet, its impact can be undermined by a single, seemingly minor detail: the buttons. The right buttons are not just functional closures; they are the exclamation point on a perfectly tailored garment. They can elevate a simple cloth to a masterpiece or reduce a finely crafted piece to an afterthought. This guide will walk you through the precise, actionable steps to selecting the perfect buttons for your frock coat, ensuring every detail contributes to a cohesive and commanding final look.
Decoding the Frock Coat: Understanding Your Canvas
Before you even consider a button, you must understand the garment itself. The frock coat is characterized by its knee-length or mid-thigh cut, fitted waist, and a structured silhouette. Unlike a modern suit jacket, its lapels are often broader, and its overall feel is more formal and historical. The buttons you choose must harmonize with these inherent characteristics. A button that works on a casual blazer will look entirely out of place on a double-breasted Victorian frock coat.
Actionable Insight: Begin by analyzing your frock coat’s style:
- Era and Inspiration: Is it a modern interpretation, a Victorian-era piece, or a military-style coat? This will dictate the appropriate button style.
-
Fabric and Weave: Heavy wool will support a larger, more substantial button. A lighter worsted wool or brocade demands a more delicate choice. The texture of the fabric should be considered – a smooth, polished fabric pairs well with a smooth button, while a tweed can handle a more textured, even rougher, button.
-
Lapel and Collar Style: A wide, peaked lapel can handle a more ornate or larger button. A narrow, notch lapel requires a more understated approach.
The Anatomy of a Button: Materials, Sizing, and Style
The world of buttons is vast, but for a frock coat, we’ll focus on the materials and styles that lend themselves to its formal nature.
Button Materials: A Hierarchy of Elegance
The material of your button is the first and most critical decision. It defines the button’s weight, feel, and visual impact.
- Brass and Gilded Metals: The quintessential choice for a classic frock coat, especially those with military or naval inspiration. Brass buttons offer a rich, golden hue and a satisfying weight. They can be polished to a high shine or left to develop a natural patina. For an extra touch of luxury, consider gilded brass, which provides a deeper, more enduring luster.
- Example: For a dark navy, double-breasted frock coat, a set of polished brass buttons with a simple anchor or crown motif provides a powerful, traditional aesthetic.
- Horn: Natural, organic, and incredibly versatile. Horn buttons, made from the horns of buffalo or cattle, come in a range of colors from creamy whites to deep blacks and mottled browns. They have a subtle sheen and a depth of color that man-made materials can’t replicate. They are an excellent choice for a less formal, more rustic frock coat made of tweed or flannel.
- Example: A single-breasted, forest green tweed frock coat would be beautifully complemented by large, dark brown mottled horn buttons.
- Corozo: A sustainable and elegant alternative to horn. Made from the tagua nut, corozo buttons have a distinctive grain and a smooth, warm feel. They can be dyed to any color, making them highly versatile. They are slightly less formal than brass but more refined than basic plastic.
- Example: A charcoal grey worsted wool frock coat would look sharp with matching dark grey corozo buttons, creating a sophisticated monochromatic look.
- Mother-of-Pearl and Abalone: Reserved for the most formal, evening-wear frock coats. These buttons possess an iridescent, shimmering quality that catches the light beautifully. They are delicate and should be used with restraint. Abalone offers a more dramatic, colorful iridescence.
- Example: A black silk moiré frock coat designed for a white-tie event could feature small, lustrous mother-of-pearl buttons.
- Leather: A niche but impactful choice. Leather buttons, often a single-knot design, are best suited for country-style or hunting frock coats. They provide a rustic, tactile element that pairs well with heavy fabrics.
- Example: A brown moleskin frock coat would be perfectly accented by simple, knotted brown leather buttons.
Button Sizing: The Proportional Rule
The size of your button must be proportional to the garment and the wearer. A button that is too large can overwhelm the coat and look cartoonish, while one that is too small can get lost and appear cheap.
- Front Closures: For the main closure buttons on the front of a frock coat, a size of 28-36 lignes (18mm-23mm) is standard.
-
Sleeve Vents: The smaller buttons on the cuffs or sleeve vents should be 20-24 lignes (13mm-15mm).
-
Actionable Tip: To determine the right size, lay a few different button sizes on your coat and step back. The correct size will feel balanced and integral to the design, not like an afterthought.
Button Style: Flat vs. Shank
The physical structure of the button is a critical, often-overlooked detail.
- Shank Buttons: These buttons have a small loop or ‘shank’ on the back, which allows the button to stand slightly proud of the fabric. This is the traditional and most appropriate style for a frock coat. It creates a cleaner look and allows the fabric to drape more naturally.
-
Flat Buttons (with holes): While common on modern suit jackets, a flat, four-hole button can look out of place on a formal frock coat. The exception is a more rustic or casual style, where a horn or leather flat button might be appropriate.
Strategic Button Placement: From Single to Double-Breasted
The arrangement and number of buttons are as important as the buttons themselves. The frock coat’s button configuration is a key part of its historical identity.
Single-Breasted Frock Coats
These typically feature a single row of buttons down the front. The number of buttons can vary, and each configuration has a different impact.
- One-Button: A modern, minimalist approach. It creates a deep V-shape and a long, clean line. Best for a more contemporary frock coat.
- Example: A sleek, black single-breasted frock coat with a single, matching black corozo button at the waist.
- Three-Button: The classic configuration. It provides a balanced, traditional look.
- Example: A grey tweed frock coat with three large, dark horn buttons. The top button should be positioned just above the waist, the middle at the waist, and the bottom just below.
- Four-Button: This is a more formal, often military-inspired configuration. It creates a higher, more closed-off silhouette.
- Example: A dark navy frock coat with four brass buttons, evenly spaced down the front.
Double-Breasted Frock Coats
This style is inherently more formal and commanding. The buttons are arranged in two vertical columns.
- “6×3” Configuration: Six buttons total, with three on each side. The wearer typically buttons only the middle button on the right side. The remaining buttons are purely decorative. This is a powerful, traditional look.
- Example: A black worsted wool double-breasted frock coat with six silver-gilt buttons, each featuring a subtle monogram.
- “8×4” Configuration: A more robust, military-style look. Eight buttons total, four on each side. This is less common but can be very striking.
Actionable Tip: When choosing buttons for a double-breasted coat, remember that symmetry is key. All buttons must be identical in size, material, and style. The visual weight of the buttons must be able to support the broad, overlapping lapels.
The Unseen Details: Cuff and Vented Buttons
Don’t overlook the smaller buttons on the cuffs and back vents. These details are a testament to the coat’s craftsmanship and your attention to detail.
- Cuff Buttons: Traditional frock coats feature “surgeon’s cuffs,” meaning the buttons are functional and the cuffs can be unbuttoned. Typically, there will be 3-4 smaller buttons on each cuff. These buttons should be a smaller version of the main closure buttons.
- Example: If your main buttons are 36-lignes brass, your cuff buttons should be 24-lignes brass, perfectly matching in style and finish.
- Back Vent Buttons: Some frock coats, especially those with a historical or equestrian influence, will have a single button at the top of the center back vent. This button should be identical to the main closure buttons.
- Actionable Tip: Ensure the thread used to sew all the buttons is a heavy-duty, high-quality thread that matches the color of the coat’s fabric. Sloppy stitching can ruin the effect of a perfect button.
Creating Cohesion: Matching Buttons to the Overall Aesthetic
The final step is to ensure that the buttons you’ve selected form a cohesive part of the overall design. Every element should tell the same story.
- Monochromatic Elegance: For a modern, understated look, choose buttons that are a very close match in color to the fabric. A dark navy coat with dark navy corozo buttons creates a clean, sophisticated silhouette. The texture of the corozo will provide subtle interest without a jarring visual contrast.
-
High-Contrast Power: For a dramatic, classic look, use a high-contrast button. A black frock coat with polished silver buttons, or a grey coat with black horn buttons. This draws the eye and makes the buttons a focal point.
- Example: A black wool frock coat with large, high-sheen silver-plated buttons makes a bold, powerful statement.
- Harmonizing Textures: The texture of the button should complement the texture of the fabric. A heavy tweed demands a substantial button with its own texture, like a mottled horn or a matte-finish metal. A smooth, fine worsted wool needs a smooth, polished button, like corozo or polished brass.
Common Pitfalls and How to Avoid Them
-
Using Plastic Buttons: This is the most common mistake. Plastic buttons, even those designed to mimic other materials, feel light and cheap. They lack the weight, depth, and character of natural or metal buttons.
-
Mixing Styles: Don’t mix button styles on a single coat. All buttons—front, cuff, and back—should be from the same family. Mixing brass and horn, for example, creates a confused and unprofessional look.
-
Poorly Sized Buttons: A button that is too big or too small will throw off the entire proportion of the garment. Always consider the coat’s scale and the wearer’s body type. A tall, broad-shouldered man can handle larger buttons than a shorter, more slender man.
-
Ignoring Thread Color: The thread used to sew on the buttons is part of the final look. A contrasting thread color can be a design choice, but a mismatched thread from poor quality work looks sloppy.
The Final Touch: A Guide to Sourcing High-Quality Buttons
Once you’ve made your decision, sourcing the right buttons is crucial.
- Specialty Haberdashery Stores: These shops often have a wide selection of high-quality buttons from around the world.
-
Online Artisans and Button Makers: Search for craftsmen who specialize in buttons made from horn, corozo, or metal. They can offer unique designs and higher quality than mass-produced options.
-
Tailors and Bespoke Suppliers: If you are having a coat made, a good tailor will have a curated selection of buttons that are appropriate for the garment.
The buttons on your frock coat are a testament to your understanding of classic menswear and your commitment to sartorial excellence. By following this guide, you will move beyond merely selecting a closure and instead, be able to craft a cohesive, powerful, and impeccably detailed garment that makes a statement without saying a word.