How to Find Hidden Gems for Your Androgynous Closet

by

Unearthing Hidden Gems for Your Androgynous Closet

The journey to building a truly exceptional androgynous wardrobe isn’t about following trends or buying from a single brand. It’s an archaeological dig, a treasure hunt, a pursuit of pieces that defy easy categorization and speak directly to your unique style. The true “hidden gems” aren’t just clothes; they’re the garments that bridge masculine and feminine aesthetics with effortless grace, offering versatility and a powerful sense of self-expression. This guide is your compass and shovel, equipping you with the strategies and mindset to unearth these sartorial treasures, transforming your closet from a collection of clothes into a curated gallery of your identity.

This guide isn’t about the “what” of androgynous fashion—the blazers, the trousers, the button-downs—but the “how.” How do you go beyond the obvious? How do you find the unexpected? We’ll delve into practical, actionable methods, from strategic thrifting and vintage hunting to redefining what you see in mainstream retail. Prepare to discard your preconceived notions and embrace a new, more adventurous way of shopping.

The Mindset Shift: Seeing Beyond Labels

Before you even step foot in a store, online or physical, you must adopt a new perspective. The biggest barrier to finding hidden gems is the rigid categorization of clothing by gender. To find true androgynous pieces, you must learn to see beyond the “men’s” and “women’s” sections and instead, focus on cut, fabric, and silhouette.

Actionable Mindset Shift:

  • Deconstruct the Garment: When you see a piece of clothing, mentally strip away the context. Is it in the men’s section? Forget that. Is it a dress? Forget that. Instead, ask: what is the shape? What is the drape? What is the texture?
    • Example: A “men’s” linen tunic might be the perfect oversized top for a flowy, asymmetrical look. A “women’s” structured blazer with strong shoulders could be the anchor for a sharp, tailored suit-inspired outfit.
  • Embrace the “Could Be”: Start asking yourself, “How could I wear this?” not “Is this for me?” A men’s flannel shirt could be a jacket. A women’s silky camisole could be a layering piece under a structured vest. This shift opens up a universe of possibilities.

  • The Power of Proportions: The magic of androgyny often lies in playing with proportions. A fitted top from the women’s section with wide-leg trousers from the men’s section creates a dynamic, balanced silhouette. A voluminous men’s cardigan over a streamlined, sleek dress is a powerful visual statement. Always think in terms of contrasting shapes.

Strategic Thrifting and Vintage Hunting: The Ultimate Treasure Trove

Thrift stores and vintage shops are the most fertile ground for finding unique androgynous pieces. They are a chaotic, uncurated jumble of decades and styles, where gender categories are often nonexistent. However, simply wandering aimlessly is inefficient. You need a strategy.

Actionable Thrifting Strategies:

  • The Men’s Section is Your Gold Mine: Don’t skip the men’s section, even if you typically shop in the women’s.
    • What to hunt for:
      • Outerwear: Men’s overcoats, trench coats, and chore jackets often have a timeless, boxy cut that is perfect for an oversized, powerful silhouette. Look for wool and heavy cottons.

      • Knitwear: Men’s crewneck and v-neck sweaters in natural fibers (cashmere, merino, wool) are often a better fit for a relaxed, slouchy look. A beautifully worn-in chunky fisherman’s sweater is a classic androgynous staple.

      • Trousers: Look for classic wool trousers, often with pleats or a high waist. They can be easily tailored for a perfect fit and provide a sharp, clean line.

  • Reimagining the Women’s Section: When you do browse the women’s section, don’t look for the obvious.

    • What to hunt for:
      • Structured Jackets: Search for blazers and jackets with strong shoulders and a defined waist. These can be paired with more masculine bottoms to create a striking balance. Think of 80s power suits and 90s minimalism.

      • Silky and Sheer Fabrics: Look for blouses, camisoles, and scarves in silk, satin, or sheer fabrics. These can be used as subtle, textural layers under blazers, vests, or chunky sweaters to add a touch of softness and contrast without being overtly feminine.

      • Unexpected Prints: A vintage women’s button-down with a bold, abstract print can be a vibrant statement piece, especially when styled with solid, neutral bottoms.

  • Tailoring is Non-Negotiable: The most important tool in your thrifting arsenal isn’t a sharp eye—it’s a good tailor. Don’t pass on a beautiful garment because the fit isn’t perfect.

    • Actionable Tailoring:
      • Trousers: A tailor can adjust the waist, taper the legs, and hem trousers to hit exactly where you want them. This is how you transform a good find into a perfect one.

      • Jackets: Shoulders are hard to alter, but a tailor can take in the waist, shorten sleeves, and change buttons to modernize a vintage piece.

      • Shirts: Oversized shirts can be tapered for a cleaner fit or have the sleeves adjusted.

The Department Store Dive: Looking Past the Mannequins

Even in mainstream retail, with its heavily curated and gendered displays, hidden gems exist. The key is to ignore the styling on the mannequins and the website models and focus on the individual items.

Actionable Department Store Strategies:

  • Blurring the Lines in Specific Departments:
    • Denim: Go to the denim section and try on jeans from both the men’s and women’s departments. Men’s straight-leg and relaxed-fit jeans can provide a great slouchy, vintage-inspired look. Women’s “boyfriend” or “mom” jeans often have a higher waist and a wider leg that can be styled in a similar fashion. The key is to ignore the name and focus on the fit.

    • Outerwear: Men’s field jackets, denim jackets, and parkas are often cut in a way that feels effortlessly cool and gender-neutral. Look for classic, utilitarian styles rather than trendy ones.

    • Knitwear: In the women’s section, seek out oversized cardigans and sweaters that are meant to be worn loose. These can mimic the feel of a men’s sweater but with a slightly different drape.

  • Accessory Cross-Pollination: Accessories are the easiest and most effective way to blur gender lines.

    • What to hunt for:
      • Belts: Men’s belts are often thicker, with more substantial buckles, which can add a touch of ruggedness to a more delicate look.

      • Bags: A men’s messenger bag or a women’s structured satchel can both work beautifully, depending on the desired aesthetic. Don’t feel limited by department.

      • Jewelry: Men’s jewelry is often bolder and heavier, while women’s is more delicate. Mix and match. A men’s silver chain with a thin gold necklace from the women’s section creates an interesting texture and style contrast.

  • The Power of Basics: The most powerful androgynous pieces are often the simplest. Invest in high-quality basics from both departments.

    • Example: A perfectly-fitting white t-shirt, a crisp poplin button-down, a pair of black trousers. The magic happens when you mix them. A men’s button-down layered under a women’s structured vest is a perfect example of this.

The Art of the Search: Online Discovery

Shopping online presents its own challenges and opportunities. The gender filters can be restrictive, but the search functionality is a powerful tool if you know what to type.

Actionable Online Search Strategies:

  • Use Specific Keywords, Not Gendered Terms: Instead of searching for “women’s blazer,” try “oversized structured jacket,” “box-cut blazer,” or “single-breasted wool jacket.”

  • Look for Fabric and Cut: Search for terms like “heavy cotton twill trousers,” “pleated wool pants,” “silk-blend button-down,” or “wide-leg denim.” These descriptions are more likely to yield a variety of results from both departments.

  • Leverage Sizing: Many brands offer unisex or gender-neutral sizing, but you can also use size as a tool. A smaller size in the men’s section or a larger size in the women’s section can create the desired silhouette. A size small men’s overshirt might be the perfect oversized fit, while a size large women’s trench coat might offer a long, drapey silhouette.

  • Explore Niche and Independent Brands: Many smaller, independent brands and designers are creating genuinely gender-fluid clothing from the ground up. Use search terms like “gender-neutral fashion,” “androgynous clothing,” or “unisex apparel.” These brands often have a unique perspective and are a goldmine for finding pieces that are intentionally designed to be worn by anyone.

Reimagining Your Existing Closet: The First Hidden Gems

Before you buy anything new, go on a hunt through your own closet. The most overlooked hidden gems are often the ones you already own.

Actionable Closet Hunt:

  • The Swap: Go through your own clothes and then a partner’s, a sibling’s, or a friend’s (with permission, of course). You might find a forgotten t-shirt, a pair of trousers that could be cuffed and worn differently, or a jacket that gets a new life when styled with your pieces.

  • The Re-style: Take a piece you’ve always worn one way and try styling it in the opposite direction.

    • Example: A fitted women’s button-down that you always wore tucked in can be worn open over a tank top as a light jacket. A men’s hoodie you always wore with jeans can be layered under a structured blazer for a high-low look.
  • The Tailoring Project: Identify five pieces in your closet that you love but don’t wear because the fit is slightly off. Take them to a tailor. A simple hem, a taper, or a button change can completely transform a garment and make it a staple.

The Power of the Final Touch: Styling and Details

Finding the gems is only half the battle. How you style them is what brings the androgynous aesthetic to life. It’s the final polish that turns a good outfit into an exceptional one.

Actionable Styling Tips:

  • The Rule of Three: Layering is the most powerful tool for creating visual interest and depth. A simple t-shirt, an open button-down, and a structured blazer create a dynamic, layered look.

  • The Cuff and Roll: A simple roll of the sleeve on a jacket or a cuff on a pair of trousers can instantly change the silhouette and feel of a piece. A precisely cuffed pair of wide-leg trousers adds a sense of intention and polish.

  • Strategic Tuck: The way you tuck in a shirt matters. A full tuck creates a clean, sharp line. A half-tuck (or French tuck) adds a more relaxed, effortless feel. An untucked shirt with a cropped jacket creates a powerful play on proportions.

  • Footwear as an Anchor: Footwear is a critical component of androgynous style. A pair of chunky boots can ground a more delicate outfit. A sharp pair of loafers can elevate a relaxed look. Sneakers add an element of casual cool. Choose footwear that balances or contrasts with the rest of your outfit.

Conclusion

Building an androgynous closet isn’t a single shopping trip; it’s a continuous practice of curiosity and re-evaluation. The hidden gems are out there, waiting in the men’s knitwear section of a vintage shop, in the back corner of a department store’s sale rack, and right in your own closet. They are the pieces that challenge gendered norms and allow you to tell your unique story. By shifting your mindset, adopting strategic shopping habits, and embracing the power of tailoring and styling, you will not only unearth these treasures but also cultivate a style that is truly and unapologetically your own.