How to Find the Perfect Lapel for Your Overcoat

by

The Definitive Guide to Finding the Perfect Lapel for Your Overcoat

Your overcoat is more than just an outer layer; it’s a statement of style, a personal signature etched in wool, cashmere, or camel hair. While the fit, fabric, and color are the primary canvases, the lapel is the frame that defines the masterpiece. It’s a subtle but powerful detail that can elevate your entire look from merely good to truly exceptional. Getting it wrong, however, can throw off your proportions, clash with your style, and diminish the coat’s overall impact. This guide is your roadmap to navigating the nuanced world of overcoat lapels, ensuring you choose a style that flatters your body, complements your wardrobe, and projects the image you desire.

The Foundation: Understanding Overcoat Lapel Styles

Before you can choose the perfect lapel, you must understand the different types and their inherent characteristics. Each style carries its own historical weight and contemporary feel.

1. The Notch Lapel (Step Lapel)

The most common and versatile lapel style, the notch lapel is defined by a triangular notch where the collar meets the lapel. It’s a sartorial workhorse, appropriate for almost any occasion and a safe, stylish choice for your first overcoat.

  • Key Characteristics: The notch is typically cut at a 90-degree angle, though some variations have a slightly wider or narrower angle. The width of the lapel itself can vary significantly.

  • Best for: The everyman. It’s the most democratic of lapels, suitable for business, casual, or formal settings. It’s particularly well-suited for single-breasted overcoats and coats with a clean, classic silhouette.

  • Actionable Advice: For a classic look, aim for a lapel width that’s proportional to your shoulder width. A medium-width notch lapel (around 3.5 inches at its widest point) is a universally flattering choice. Avoid excessively narrow or wide lapels unless you have a specific aesthetic in mind. For example, a man with broad shoulders will find a wider notch lapel (4 inches) balances his frame, while a slender man will look better in a slightly narrower one (3 inches).

2. The Peak Lapel (Pointed Lapel)

Distinguished by its points that extend upwards and outwards towards the shoulders, the peak lapel is a bold, formal, and authoritative choice. It draws the eye horizontally, broadening the shoulders and creating a powerful V-shape.

  • Key Characteristics: The lapel’s “peaks” point sharply towards the shoulders. This style is often associated with double-breasted coats, tuxedos, and formal suiting.

  • Best for: The sartorialist. This is the lapel for making a statement. It’s a fantastic option for a formal overcoat, a double-breasted coat, or for anyone who wants to project an air of confidence and authority.

  • Actionable Advice: The peak lapel should be chosen with intention. It’s less versatile than the notch lapel and can look out of place with overly casual attire. When choosing a peak lapel, pay close attention to the angle of the peak. A steeper angle is generally more aggressive and modern, while a more gradual, rounded angle is classic and elegant. Ensure the peak aligns with the outer edge of your shoulder, creating a seamless, powerful line. For a double-breasted overcoat, the peak lapel is the gold standard.

3. The Shawl Lapel (Rolled Collar)

A continuous, rounded lapel that flows seamlessly from the collar without a break. The shawl lapel is the epitome of evening wear and a symbol of luxury and refinement.

  • Key Characteristics: A continuous, un-notched roll. The width can vary, but it’s typically wider than a standard notch lapel.

  • Best for: The aesthete. This lapel is almost exclusively reserved for formal occasions. It’s a perfect match for a tuxedo-style overcoat or a smoking jacket. It adds a touch of old-world glamour and sophistication.

  • Actionable Advice: This is not a lapel for your daily commute. If you’re buying a separate overcoat specifically for black-tie events, the shawl lapel is the definitive choice. When selecting one, consider the material. A satin or silk shawl lapel on a wool or cashmere coat adds a beautiful textural contrast. The width of the shawl lapel should be chosen carefully; a wider roll is more traditional and formal, while a very narrow one can look a bit dated.

4. The Ulster Lapel (Peaked Notch Lapel)

A variation of the notch lapel, the Ulster is characterized by its distinct, pointed upper lapel that creates a step effect, almost like a peak lapel and a notch lapel combined. It’s a rugged, yet sophisticated, style often found on heavier, traditional overcoats.

  • Key Characteristics: A prominent step or notch, where the upper lapel points upwards. Often paired with a double-breasted closure and a belt.

  • Best for: The traditionalist. The Ulster lapel is ideal for a classic, heavy-duty overcoat meant for cold weather. It has a vintage, almost military feel that exudes timeless style.

  • Actionable Advice: This lapel is a perfect match for a heavy tweed or herringbone overcoat. Because of its inherent bulk and formality, it’s best paired with a structured, sturdy fabric. If you’re building a wardrobe for colder climates and want a coat that is both stylish and practical, the Ulster lapel on a double-breasted overcoat is a top-tier choice. Ensure the lapel size is substantial enough to balance the coat’s robust fabric and silhouette.

The Rule of Proportions: Matching the Lapel to Your Body Type

The lapel isn’t just an aesthetic choice; it’s a tool for creating a balanced and flattering silhouette. The right lapel can make you look taller, broader, or more slender.

1. For the Broad-Shouldered or Muscular Frame

  • The Problem: A narrow lapel on a broad frame will make your shoulders look disproportionately wide and your head appear small. The lapel will get lost, and the overall effect will be jarring.

  • The Solution: Choose a wider lapel. A wider notch lapel (3.5-4 inches) or a prominent peak lapel will create a sense of balance. The width of the lapel should be proportional to your shoulder breadth, drawing the eye down and creating a harmonious line from your shoulders to your waist.

  • Concrete Example: A man with a 46-inch chest and broad shoulders should opt for a 4-inch notch lapel or a well-defined peak lapel on his overcoat. This width will align with the scale of his frame, creating a strong, balanced look.

2. For the Slender or Narrow-Shouldered Frame

  • The Problem: A very wide lapel can overpower a slender frame, making the coat look ill-fitting and your shoulders appear narrow in comparison.

  • The Solution: Opt for a narrower lapel. A classic 3-inch notch lapel is an excellent choice. It will complement your proportions without overwhelming your frame. The peak lapel can also work, but ensure the points are not overly aggressive or wide.

  • Concrete Example: A man with a 38-inch chest and a slender build should look for an overcoat with a 3-inch notch lapel. This narrower width will be in scale with his body, making the coat look custom-made and elegant rather than baggy.

3. For the Shorter Stature

  • The Problem: A very wide, or excessively long, lapel can visually shorten your torso and make you look squat.

  • The Solution: Choose a lapel with a slightly higher gorge (the point where the collar and lapel meet). A higher gorge creates a longer, cleaner line from the neck to the waist, elongating the torso. A notch lapel of standard width (around 3 inches) is often the safest bet. Avoid overly wide or bulky Ulster-style lapels.

  • Concrete Example: A man who is 5’7″ should look for an overcoat with a standard width notch lapel and a gorge that sits relatively high on the chest. This will create a streamlined vertical line, making him appear taller.

Practical Application: Matching the Lapel to Your Wardrobe and Occasion

Your overcoat lapel shouldn’t exist in a vacuum. It must harmonize with the rest of your clothing and the environments you’ll be wearing it in.

1. The Overcoat for Business and Formal Wear

  • The Goal: A professional, polished, and authoritative look.

  • Lapel Choices: The peak lapel is the undisputed king here. On a charcoal or navy double-breasted overcoat, it’s a powerful statement of intent. The notch lapel is also an excellent, more conservative choice for a single-breasted coat.

  • How-to: If your daily uniform is a suit, a peak lapel overcoat will seamlessly match the formality of your inner layers. For a single-breasted suit, a notch lapel overcoat is a classic and foolproof option. The key is to match the formality of the lapel. A shawl lapel over a business suit is a definite no. A notch lapel on a tuxedo overcoat is also a mismatch.

2. The Overcoat for Casual and Smart-Casual Wear

  • The Goal: A stylish, versatile, and relaxed look.

  • Lapel Choices: The notch lapel is the most versatile and appropriate for casual wear. It works perfectly over jeans and a sweater, or chinos and a button-down shirt. The Ulster lapel can also be a fantastic choice for a rugged, heavy overcoat worn with more casual textures like corduroy or denim.

  • How-to: Think about the material. A heavy wool or tweed overcoat with a substantial notch or Ulster lapel will complement the relaxed feel of casual wear. For example, a camel-colored single-breasted overcoat with a classic notch lapel is the perfect partner for a grey sweater and dark denim. It’s an easy, elegant look that bridges the gap between casual and polished.

3. The Overcoat for Evening and Black-Tie Events

  • The Goal: Unimpeachable elegance and a touch of theatricality.

  • Lapel Choices: The shawl lapel is the quintessential choice for this occasion. The peak lapel is also an acceptable, and often more aggressive, option.

  • How-to: If you’re attending a gala, a wedding, or a black-tie event, your overcoat should signal the same level of formality as your tuxedo. A black or midnight blue overcoat with a silk or satin shawl lapel is the ultimate expression of this. This is where you can be bold and embrace a lapel that stands out from the rest of your wardrobe. The visual continuity of the shawl lapel creates a powerful, refined line that complements the elegance of a tuxedo.

Final Checks: The Small Details That Make a Big Difference

Once you’ve settled on a lapel style, there are a few final details to consider before making your purchase. These small elements are what separate a good overcoat from a great one.

  • The Lapel Roll: A well-crafted lapel should have a soft, natural roll from the shoulder seam down to the first button. It should not be flat or pressed lifelessly. This roll is a sign of quality construction and contributes to the garment’s three-dimensional shape.

  • The Gorge: The gorge, or the notch where the collar and lapel meet, should be clean and well-defined. On a classic overcoat, the gorge should sit a little higher than the gorge on a suit jacket, creating a longer, more flattering line.

  • The Lapel Buttonhole: On a classic overcoat, the left lapel often has a buttonhole (the “boutonnière hole”). While it’s largely decorative today, its presence is a hallmark of a traditional, well-made garment. Ensure it’s neatly stitched and positioned correctly.

  • The Fabric: The lapel is a component of the entire coat, and its interaction with the fabric is crucial. A thin lapel on a heavy tweed coat will look off. A wide lapel on a lightweight cashmere coat might look too bulky. The lapel should always be in scale with the fabric’s weight and texture. For a thick, heavy wool, a substantial lapel is a must. For a finer, lighter material, a more delicate lapel will suffice.

The Final Verdict: Building Your Lapel Strategy

Choosing the perfect lapel for your overcoat is about more than just personal preference; it’s a strategic decision based on proportion, occasion, and personal style. The notch lapel is your versatile foundation, the peak lapel is your statement piece, the shawl lapel is your formal flourish, and the Ulster lapel is your rugged traditionalist. By understanding these styles and how they interact with your body and your wardrobe, you can select an overcoat that not only keeps you warm but also serves as a powerful expression of your individual style. The right lapel is a silent declaration of your taste, and with this guide, you have the knowledge to make that declaration with confidence and impeccable style.