How to Make a Stable Emulsion with High Water Content

by

Crafting a Stable, High-Water Content Emulsion: A Practical Guide for Personal Care Formulators

Introduction

The demand for lightweight, refreshing, and non-greasy personal care products is at an all-time high. Consumers are seeking formulations that hydrate and nourish without leaving a heavy, occlusive residue. This trend has made high-water content emulsions—those with a water phase exceeding 75%—the holy grail for formulators. However, creating a stable, elegant, and effective high-water emulsion is a significant challenge. The delicate balance between oil and water, the choice of emulsifier, and the shear force applied during manufacturing are all critical factors that can lead to separation, instability, and a poor user experience.

This guide provides a comprehensive, hands-on roadmap to formulating stable emulsions with a water content of over 85% for the personal care industry. We will move beyond the theoretical and focus on practical, actionable steps, using real-world examples and ingredient suggestions. You will learn how to select the right emulsifiers, manage viscosity, choose effective stabilizers, and optimize your manufacturing process to create a flawless, stable product every time.

Understanding the Fundamentals: The High-Water Challenge

The primary challenge in high-water content emulsions is the vast disparity in the volume of the two phases. In a traditional O/W (oil-in-water) emulsion, the oil droplets are dispersed in a continuous water phase. As the water phase volume increases, the distance between the oil droplets widens. The emulsifier, which forms a film around each droplet, has a harder time maintaining this separation against the forces of gravity and Brownian motion. This leads to droplet coalescence, where smaller droplets merge to form larger ones, eventually leading to phase separation.

A stable high-water emulsion, therefore, requires a robust, multi-faceted strategy. It’s not just about picking a single emulsifier; it’s about building a stable framework that physically prevents the oil droplets from coming together. This framework is comprised of three key components:

  1. The Primary Emulsifier System: The core of your emulsion, responsible for creating the initial dispersion.

  2. The Co-Emulsifier/Stabilizer System: Ingredients that reinforce the primary emulsifier and build viscosity.

  3. The Rheology Modifier/Thickener: The agent that provides the final structure and texture, preventing settling.

Let’s dive into each of these components with practical, step-by-step guidance.

Part 1: Selecting Your Emulsifier System for High-Water Formulas

The choice of emulsifier is the single most important decision you will make. For high-water content emulsions, you cannot rely on simple, single-ingredient emulsifiers. You need a powerful, robust system, often a combination of non-ionic and polymeric emulsifiers.

Actionable Strategy: The Polymeric Emulsifier and Co-Emulsifier Duo

For high-water content, an oil-in-water emulsion is the only practical option. The most effective approach is to build a system around a polymeric emulsifier. Polymeric emulsifiers are large molecules that can form a strong, protective shield around the oil droplets, preventing them from coalescing.

  • Step 1: Choose Your Primary Polymeric Emulsifier. These are often pre-neutralized, making them easy to use. They function not just as an emulsifier but also as a thickener and stabilizer.
    • Example A (Beginner-Friendly): Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer. This is a highly effective, low-viscosity emulsifier that thickens as it is neutralized. It can be a workhorse in your high-water formulas. It provides a clean, non-tacky feel.

    • Example B (Advanced): Sodium Acrylates Copolymer (and) Lecithin. This is a more sophisticated system that leverages the power of a polymeric thickener combined with a natural co-emulsifier. It creates a smooth, silicone-like feel without the use of silicones.

  • Step 2: Incorporate a Secondary, Low-HLB Co-Emulsifier. A high-HLB emulsifier (like most polymeric ones) is great for the water phase, but you need a co-emulsifier that loves the oil phase to truly lock everything in place. A low-HLB emulsifier helps reduce the interfacial tension between the oil and water phases, making it easier for the primary emulsifier to do its job.

    • Example: Sorbitan Oleate (HLB ~4.3). This ingredient is excellent for stabilizing the oil droplets. It sits at the interface, helping to create a tighter, more cohesive film around the oil phase. Use this in your oil phase before mixing.

Concrete Example of an Emulsifier System (for a 90% Water Formula):

  • Water Phase: Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer (Carbomer-type, 0.3%)

  • Oil Phase: Sorbitan Oleate (0.5%), a light ester oil like Ethylhexyl Palmitate (5%)

  • Neutralizer: Sodium Hydroxide (0.1% or as needed to pH 6.0-7.0)

Why this works: The polymeric emulsifier provides the bulk of the thickening and stabilization in the water phase. The low-HLB sorbitan oleate, dissolved in the oil phase, helps to create a more stable, smaller oil droplet size, which is critical for long-term stability in high-water systems.

Part 2: Managing Viscosity and Rheology for Stability

Viscosity is not just about feel; it’s a critical component of stability. In a high-water emulsion, the continuous water phase is highly mobile. Without sufficient viscosity, the oil droplets will simply float to the top (creaming) or sink to the bottom (sedimentation), leading to separation. A thickener is not just a thickener; it’s a stabilizer.

Actionable Strategy: Building a Multi-Layered Viscosity Profile

You need to create a yield stress—a point at which the emulsion will not flow under the influence of gravity. This requires a two-pronged approach: a primary thickener for the bulk viscosity and a secondary gum or polymer for network building.

  • Step 1: Choose Your Primary Thickener. The polymeric emulsifiers from Part 1 often serve this purpose, but sometimes you need more.
    • Example: Hydroxyethylcellulose. This is a classic, non-ionic thickener that works over a wide pH range. It provides a clean, smooth feel and excellent viscosity without being tacky. Use at 0.5-1.5%.
  • Step 2: Add a Stabilizing Gum. Gums are excellent for building a robust, three-dimensional network in the water phase. This network physically traps the oil droplets, preventing them from moving and coalescing.
    • Example: Xanthan Gum. A highly effective, natural polysaccharide. Use it at low concentrations (0.1-0.2%). It creates a shear-thinning texture, meaning the product feels thick in the bottle but spreads easily on the skin. You must hydrate it properly to avoid clumping.

Concrete Example of a Viscosity System (for an 88% Water Formula):

  • Water Phase: Hydroxyethylcellulose (1.0%), Xanthan Gum (0.15%), Propylene Glycol (3%)

  • Oil Phase: Cetearyl Alcohol (3%), Stearic Acid (2%)

  • Emulsifier: Glyceryl Stearate SE (3%) – a complete, self-emulsifying system

Why this works: The Hydroxyethylcellulose provides the initial viscosity and bulk. The Xanthan Gum creates a gel network that holds everything in place. The Glyceryl Stearate SE is a tried-and-true emulsifier, and the Cetearyl Alcohol and Stearic Acid are fatty alcohols and acids that provide “body” and co-emulsifying properties, further strengthening the emulsion structure. The presence of these fatty alcohols is a formulator’s secret to creating a stable, elegant feel in many emulsions.

Part 3: The Critical Role of Co-Emulsifiers and “Body Builders”

In high-water emulsions, you need more than just a primary emulsifier. You need ingredients that create a stable, structured interface between the oil and water. These are your co-emulsifiers and body builders, and they are typically fatty alcohols or fatty acids.

Actionable Strategy: Building a Liquid Crystal Structure

The magic of stable emulsions often lies in the formation of a liquid crystal structure at the interface. This structure is a highly organized, multi-layered film of emulsifier molecules and fatty alcohols. It is much more robust than a simple monolayer film.

  • Step 1: Incorporate Fatty Alcohols. Cetyl Alcohol, Cetearyl Alcohol, and Stearyl Alcohol are classic examples. They have a long hydrocarbon chain that aligns with the oil phase and a hydroxyl group that interacts with the water phase. They are not emulsifiers themselves but act as powerful stabilizers.
    • Example: Cetearyl Alcohol. Use this at 2-5%. It adds “body,” viscosity, and a rich feel while significantly enhancing emulsion stability. It works synergistically with most emulsifiers.
  • Step 2: Utilize Fatty Acids. Stearic Acid is a common example. Like fatty alcohols, it helps build the interfacial film. It also contributes to the pearlescent look of some emulsions and can have a slight thickening effect.
    • Example: Stearic Acid. Use at 1-3%. It is often used in conjunction with a neutralizing agent like Triethanolamine to form a soap in-situ, which is a powerful emulsifier in its own right.

Concrete Example of a Co-Emulsifier System (for a 92% Water Formula):

  • Water Phase: Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer (0.5%), Glycerin (5%)

  • Oil Phase: Light silicone like Dimethicone (1%), Cetyl Alcohol (2%), Jojoba Oil (1%)

  • Neutralizer: Arginine (0.1% or as needed to pH 6.0)

Why this works: The Acrylates/C10-30 Alkyl Acrylate Crosspolymer is the primary emulsifier/thickener. The Cetyl Alcohol is the body builder that creates the critical liquid crystal structure at the interface, locking the small oil droplets in place. Glycerin helps to manage the viscosity and provides a humectant function. The Arginine is a gentle, skin-friendly amino acid that acts as a neutralizing agent.

Part 4: The Art and Science of Manufacturing

Even with the perfect formula, a poorly executed manufacturing process will result in an unstable emulsion. The goal is to create the smallest possible oil droplets and disperse them evenly within the water phase. This requires controlled temperature and high shear.

Actionable Strategy: The High-Shear, Controlled-Temperature Process

  • Step 1: Prepare Your Phases Separately.
    • Water Phase: Combine all water-soluble ingredients (water, glycerin, thickeners, gums, preservatives). Heat to 75-80°C. Hydrate your gums properly by premixing them with a small amount of glycerin or a portion of your oil phase to prevent clumping.

    • Oil Phase: Combine all oil-soluble ingredients (oils, fatty alcohols, fatty acids, low-HLB emulsifiers). Heat to 75-80°C. Ensure everything is fully melted and clear.

  • Step 2: Add the Oil Phase to the Water Phase. This is a critical step. Add the oil phase to the water phase slowly and under high shear. This is not a gentle stirring process. You need a high-shear mixer (homogenizer) to physically break the oil droplets into a tiny, uniform size.

    • Why high shear? High shear energy is what creates the tiny, sub-micron oil droplets that are essential for long-term stability. A simple propeller mixer will not suffice for high-water systems. You are physically forcing the oil into the water.
  • Step 3: Begin the Cooling Process. Once the oil has been fully incorporated and the emulsion looks homogenous, switch to a lower-shear mixing speed. Cool the emulsion slowly with continuous, gentle stirring. This allows the liquid crystal structure to form properly.
    • Example: Cool from 75°C to 45°C over 15-20 minutes. At 45°C, add your heat-sensitive ingredients (fragrance, active ingredients, some preservatives).
  • Step 4: The Final Check and Adjustment. Once the emulsion has cooled to room temperature, check the pH and viscosity. Neutralize if needed (e.g., if using a carbomer) to reach the target pH of 5.5-6.5. This final step is crucial as it activates many polymeric thickeners and preservatives.

Common Manufacturing Pitfalls to Avoid:

  • Adding the water phase to the oil phase. This is a fundamental mistake. The continuous phase (water) must be the larger volume.

  • Insufficient shear. Trying to emulsify a high-water system with a hand blender or propeller mixer will result in a weak, unstable product.

  • Cooling too quickly. Rushing the cooling process can shock the emulsion and prevent the liquid crystal structure from forming correctly.

Part 5: Advanced Stabilization: The pH, Preservative, and Active Challenge

A stable emulsion is a complex system, and introducing actives, preservatives, or changing the pH can throw everything out of whack. High-water content makes this even more precarious.

Actionable Strategy: The “Test and Tweak” Method

  • Step 1: Manage pH carefully. Many emulsifiers and thickeners are pH-sensitive. For example, carbomers require a neutral or slightly alkaline pH (around 6-7) to thicken. Xanthan gum is more pH-tolerant but can be affected by very high or low pH.
    • Action: Formulate with a broad-range buffer system in mind. Use a preservative system that works well in your target pH range.
  • Step 2: Select a Robust Preservative System. High-water content means a high risk of microbial growth. Your preservative system must be effective.
    • Example: A combination of Phenoxyethanol (0.5%) and Ethylhexylglycerin (0.5%) is a robust, well-established system. It is effective against bacteria, yeast, and mold and works in a broad pH range.
  • Step 3: Incorporate Actives with Caution. Many active ingredients (like AHAs, Vitamin C, or botanical extracts) can be tricky. They often have a low pH or contain electrolytes that can break a fragile emulsion.
    • Action: Add actives in the cool-down phase (below 45°C). Use a higher concentration of your stabilizer (e.g., Xanthan Gum or your polymeric emulsifier) to create a more resilient emulsion that can withstand the addition of the active.

Concrete Example of an Advanced Formula with Actives (for an 85% Water Serum):

  • Water Phase: Distilled Water (85.2%), Glycerin (5%), Sodium Polyacrylate (1.0%, a polymer thickener/emulsifier)

  • Oil Phase: Caprylic/Capric Triglyceride (4%), Cetyl Alcohol (2%), Olive Squalane (2%)

  • Actives Phase (added below 45°C): Niacinamide (3%), Phenoxyethanol (1%)

Why this works: The sodium polyacrylate is a powerful, electrolyte-tolerant thickener and emulsifier that can handle the addition of the Niacinamide. The Cetyl Alcohol provides body and stability. The combination of Glycerin and Niacinamide provides powerful hydration and skin benefits without compromising the emulsion. The Olive Squalane is a light, stable oil that gives a silky feel.

Conclusion

Creating a stable, high-water content emulsion is a skill that blends art with scientific rigor. It requires moving beyond the single-emulsifier approach and building a multi-layered, synergistic system. By strategically combining a primary emulsifier, a robust co-emulsifier/body builder, and a powerful rheology modifier, you can create a structured, elegant, and stable emulsion that can withstand the test of time.

The key takeaways are clear:

  • Use a polymeric emulsifier. These provide the bulk of your stability and thickening power.

  • Build an interfacial film. Use fatty alcohols and fatty acids to create a liquid crystal structure.

  • Create a yield stress. Use gums and thickeners to build a network that physically traps the oil droplets.

  • Employ high shear during manufacturing. This is non-negotiable for creating tiny, stable oil droplets.

  • Be methodical. Test your ingredients and process, and add sensitive actives and preservatives at the correct temperature and stage.

Mastering these principles will allow you to formulate innovative, high-performance personal care products that meet the growing consumer demand for lightweight, refreshing, and effective hydration.