How to Make Old Plimsolls Look New Again: DIY Restoration Tips

by

A Definitive Guide to Restoring Your Old Plimsolls

Plimsolls, those timeless, canvas-and-rubber-soled classics, are a wardrobe staple for good reason. They’re comfortable, versatile, and effortlessly stylish. But like all good things, they eventually show their age. The once-pristine white canvas turns a sad shade of grey, the rubber foxing yellows and scuffs, and the laces fray. Before you relegate them to the back of your closet or the trash can, know that there’s a world of DIY restoration just waiting for you to discover. This guide will take you step-by-step through the process of bringing your old plimsolls back to life, transforming them from worn-out to “just bought.”

The Essential Toolkit: What You’ll Need

Before we dive into the restoration process, let’s gather our arsenal. Having the right tools on hand will make the job infinitely easier and more effective. You can find most of these items around your house or at a local hardware store or supermarket.

  • For Cleaning the Canvas and Laces:
    • Old toothbrush or soft-bristled brush

    • Mild laundry detergent or dish soap

    • Baking soda

    • White vinegar

    • Stain remover (oxygen-based is excellent for white canvas)

    • A small bucket or basin

    • Clean, absorbent towels

  • For Cleaning the Rubber Soles and Foxing:

    • Magic eraser (melamine foam)

    • Baking soda paste

    • Rubbing alcohol (isopropyl alcohol)

    • Cotton swabs

    • Fine-grit sandpaper (120-220 grit) for stubborn scuffs

  • For Whitening and Brightening:

    • Fabric whitener or brightener (e.g., Rit Whitener & Brightener)

    • Hydrogen peroxide (3% solution)

    • Sunlight (a natural bleaching agent)

  • For Restoration and Protection:

    • White shoe paint or acrylic paint (for canvas)

    • White rubber shoe paint or a paint marker (for soles)

    • Shoe protector spray (waterproofing and stain resistance)

    • New laces (a simple, yet transformative, upgrade)

Step 1: The Initial Assessment and Prep Work

The first step in any successful restoration is a thorough examination. Lay your plimsolls out and take a good look at their condition. This will help you decide which treatments are necessary.

  • Separate the Laces: Untie and remove the laces. This is crucial. Laces trap dirt and can prevent you from getting a deep clean on the tongue and eyelets. They are often the dirtiest part of the shoe and need separate attention.

  • Dry Brush: Use a stiff, dry brush or an old toothbrush to gently brush away any loose dirt, dust, and debris from the canvas and soles. This pre-cleaning step prevents you from turning dry dirt into muddy smudges when you introduce water.

Step 2: Deep Cleaning the Canvas

This is where the magic begins. A proper deep clean will remove years of grime and stains, forming the foundation for a brilliant restoration.

Method 1: The Baking Soda and Vinegar Scrub

This classic combination is a powerful, yet gentle, cleaner and deodorizer.

  • Create the Paste: In a small bowl, mix equal parts baking soda and white vinegar until it forms a thick paste. The mixture will fizz and bubble; this is normal.

  • Apply and Scrub: Using an old toothbrush, apply the paste generously to the canvas, focusing on any stained or discolored areas. Scrub in small, circular motions, working the paste into the fabric.

  • Let It Sit: Let the paste dry completely on the shoes. As it dries, it will pull out dirt and odors. This usually takes a few hours.

  • Brush It Off: Once the paste is a dry, chalky consistency, simply brush it off with a dry brush. You’ll see the dirt lifted away with the powder.

Method 2: The Stain-Specific Treatment

For particularly stubborn stains, a more targeted approach is needed.

  • For Grass Stains: Apply a small amount of an oxygen-based stain remover directly to the stain and let it sit for 15-20 minutes before scrubbing gently.

  • For Ink Stains: Dab a cotton ball soaked in rubbing alcohol onto the stain. Blot, don’t rub, to avoid spreading the ink.

  • For General Grime: Create a cleaning solution by mixing a few drops of mild laundry detergent or dish soap with warm water. Submerge your brush in the solution and scrub the canvas, working from the inside out.

Pro-Tip for White Canvas: After scrubbing with your chosen method, rinse the canvas thoroughly with cold water. Squeeze out excess water with a towel, but do not wring the shoes, as this can damage their structure. Stuff the shoes with paper towels or newspaper to help them retain their shape and absorb moisture as they dry.

Step 3: Revitalizing the Rubber Soles and Foxing

The yellowing and scuff marks on the rubber are often the biggest giveaway that your plimsolls are old. Fortunately, this is one of the easiest parts to restore.

Method 1: The Magic Eraser Method

The melamine foam of a magic eraser is a micro-abrasive that works wonders on rubber.

  • Dampen and Erase: Wet the magic eraser slightly and squeeze out the excess water. Use it to scrub the rubber soles and the white foxing around the shoe. You’ll see scuffs and dirt disappear instantly.

  • Rinse and Dry: Wipe down the rubber with a damp cloth to remove any residue.

Method 2: The Baking Soda Paste and Toothbrush

This is an alternative if you don’t have a magic eraser.

  • Create the Paste: Mix baking soda with just enough water to form a thick paste.

  • Scrub: Apply the paste to the rubber with an old toothbrush and scrub vigorously. The mild abrasive nature of the baking soda will lift scuffs and dirt.

  • Rinse: Wipe away the paste with a damp cloth.

Method 3: For Extreme Yellowing

If the rubber has severe yellowing, a slightly more aggressive approach is needed.

  • Hydrogen Peroxide Treatment: In a well-ventilated area, wear gloves and apply a thin layer of 3% hydrogen peroxide solution to the yellowed rubber using a cotton swab or a small brush.

  • Sunlight Activation: Place the shoes in direct sunlight. The UV rays will activate the hydrogen peroxide, which helps reverse the yellowing. Check on them every 30 minutes to an hour. Do not leave them for too long, as this can potentially damage the rubber.

  • Rinse: Once the yellowing has faded, rinse the rubber thoroughly with water and let it dry.

Step 4: Brightening and Whitening the Canvas

This step is for those seeking that “factory fresh” look. After a thorough cleaning, you might find the canvas is cleaner, but still not as bright as you’d like.

Method 1: Fabric Whitener

  • Follow the Instructions: Use a commercial fabric whitener or brightener according to the package directions. Many are designed to be added to a basin of water where you can soak the shoes.

  • Soak and Rinse: Follow the recommended soaking time. Afterward, rinse the shoes thoroughly to remove all chemicals.

Method 2: The Sunlight Bleach

  • Place in Direct Sunlight: After a thorough wash and rinse, place the wet plimsolls in direct sunlight. The sun’s UV rays have a natural bleaching effect that can brighten white canvas.

  • Let Them Dry Completely: Let the shoes dry completely in the sun. This also helps to prevent mildew and odor.

Step 5: The Final Restoration: Painting and Protection

Sometimes, a deep clean isn’t enough to get rid of permanent stains or scuffs. This is when painting can be a game-changer.

Method 1: Painting the Canvas

  • Masking: Before you begin, use painter’s tape to carefully mask off the rubber soles and foxing. This will prevent any paint from getting on them.

  • Choose the Right Paint: Use a dedicated fabric or shoe paint, or a high-quality acrylic paint mixed with a fabric medium. This ensures the paint remains flexible and won’t crack.

  • Apply Thin Coats: Apply the paint in thin, even coats using a small brush. It’s better to do two or three thin coats than one thick one, which can look caked-on and unnatural.

  • Let It Dry: Allow each coat to dry completely before applying the next.

  • Unmask: Carefully remove the painter’s tape once the final coat is dry.

Method 2: Restoring the Rubber

  • Rubber-Specific Paint: For truly battered soles, you can use a white rubber shoe paint pen or a dedicated rubber paint. These are designed to adhere to the material without flaking.

  • Precise Application: Use the pen or a small, fine-tipped brush to carefully paint over any remaining scuffs or yellowed areas on the soles and foxing. Work slowly and methodically.

Step 6: The Finishing Touches

Your plimsolls are now looking brand new, but there are a few final steps to secure their long-term freshness.

  • New Laces: A new pair of crisp, white laces can make an astonishing difference. They provide a final pop of brightness and complete the “new shoe” illusion.

  • Waterproofing: Apply a shoe protector spray, which provides a barrier against future stains and water damage. Follow the product’s instructions for application and drying time. This is a crucial step to protect your hard work.

  • Deodorize: If the shoes still have a faint odor, you can sprinkle a small amount of baking soda inside and let it sit overnight. In the morning, shake it out.

Conclusion: A Fresh Start for Your Favorites

You’ve now transformed your tired, old plimsolls into a pair that looks ready for the streets again. This process isn’t just about cleaning; it’s a sustainable act of renewal, breathing new life into a beloved item. The satisfaction of taking something worn-out and making it look new again is a reward in itself. By following these practical, step-by-step instructions, you’ve not only restored your shoes but also gained a valuable skill that can be applied to many other items in your wardrobe. So go ahead, lace them up, and step out with confidence.