How to Spot Quality in Vintage Clothing: What to Look For

by

The Savvy Shopper’s Handbook: A Guide to Spotting Quality in Vintage Clothing

The thrill of the hunt is a core part of the vintage shopping experience. Unearthing a hidden gem, a piece with history and character, feels like a personal victory. But amidst the racks of moth-eaten cardigans and frayed denim, how do you find the true treasures? The key lies in shifting your perspective from simply looking at a garment to truly seeing it. A discerning eye for quality is the most valuable tool in your vintage arsenal. This comprehensive guide will equip you with the knowledge and practical skills to confidently differentiate between a well-made, enduring piece and a flimsy imitation. We’ll go beyond the surface, diving deep into the tangible signs of craftsmanship that define a garment’s longevity and value.

Beyond the Tag: The Fabric and Feel Test

The first and most immediate indicator of quality is the fabric itself. Before you even look at a seam, your hands and eyes can tell you a great deal. A cheap garment will often feel thin, rough, or synthetic, lacking the weight and drape of a quality textile.

Natural Fibers are Your Best Friends

Prioritize natural fibers. Wool, cotton, linen, and silk are not only comfortable and breathable but also far more durable than their synthetic counterparts.

  • Wool: Look for a dense, tightly woven wool, not a loose, fuzzy knit. A quality wool sweater will feel substantial and have a natural spring to it. When you gently stretch it, it should snap back into place without losing its shape.

  • Cotton: High-quality cotton will feel soft and smooth, not scratchy or stiff. A good way to test is to hold it up to the light. Tightly woven cotton, like a fine poplin or broadcloth, will be less see-through than a cheap, loosely woven fabric.

  • Linen: Real linen, especially vintage linen, has a distinct texture and weight. It should feel cool to the touch and have a natural, almost crisp hand. Be wary of flimsy, thin linen blends that wrinkle excessively and lack body.

  • Silk: Genuine silk feels incredibly smooth and has a beautiful, natural sheen. To a trained eye, the luster of real silk is different from the artificial shine of polyester. A quick test is to gently rub the fabric between your fingers; real silk will feel warm and almost ‘grippy,’ while polyester will feel slick and slippery.

The Drape and Weight Test

A quality fabric will have a certain weight and drape. Hold the garment up by the shoulders and let it hang. A well-made dress or blouse will fall in soft, elegant folds. A cheap garment will often hang stiffly, with little movement, or cling unpleasantly to itself. For a knit garment, the weight should be evenly distributed. A good sweater will feel substantial, not flimsy or heavy in a way that suggests a loose, unsupportive weave.

The Seam Detective: Uncovering Construction Secrets

The construction of a garment is the blueprint of its quality. How the pieces are put together is a definitive sign of whether it was built to last or simply thrown together.

The Inside Story: Seam Finishes

Always turn the garment inside out. The interior tells the true story. Quality garments will have finished seams that prevent fraying.

  • Serged seams: Look for tight, consistent serging. The stitches should be close together and not loose or unraveling.

  • French seams: These are the gold standard, especially in vintage couture and high-end blouses. A French seam encloses the raw edge of the fabric completely within the seam itself, creating a clean, professional finish on both sides. This is a clear indicator of superior craftsmanship.

  • Bound seams: Another sign of quality, bound seams use a separate strip of fabric to enclose the raw edge. This is common in unlined jackets and coats. The binding should be neatly applied and secure.

  • Zig-zag stitches: A simple zig-zag stitch over the raw edge is a basic finish. While not as high-end as a French or bound seam, a well-executed, tight zig-zag is still preferable to a raw, fraying edge.

Stitch Count and Consistency

Examine the stitching itself. Quality stitching is even, tight, and has a high stitch count per inch. The higher the stitch count, the stronger and more durable the seam. Loose, uneven stitches are a red flag. On a button-down shirt, check the placket and collar. The stitching should be straight and consistent, with no puckering or skipped stitches.

Matching Patterns and Symmetry

This detail is a hallmark of a garment made with care. If the garment has a plaid, striped, or floral pattern, check to see if the patterns are matched at the seams.

  • Plaid: On a plaid jacket or skirt, the lines of the plaid should match up at the side seams and across the pockets. This takes extra fabric and careful cutting, and is a sign of a high-quality piece.

  • Stripes: Stripes on a striped shirt or dress should align perfectly where the sleeves meet the body and at the side seams.

  • Symmetry: Both sides of the garment should be perfectly symmetrical. The lapels of a coat should be the same size, the pockets should be at the same height, and the sleeves should be identical in length and shape.

The Hardware and Hems: The Details that Matter

Small details often reveal the biggest truths. The quality of the buttons, zippers, and the finish of a hem can tell you if a garment was made to last or simply to sell.

Buttons and Buttonholes

  • Buttons: Quality buttons are often made from natural materials like mother-of-pearl, wood, or corozo nut. Plastic buttons can be a sign of a cheaper garment, but even then, a quality plastic button will be thick and well-finished, not thin and flimsy. The buttons should be securely sewn on with a shank for a professional finish, allowing for easy buttoning without straining the fabric.

  • Buttonholes: A well-made buttonhole is a small work of art. The stitching should be dense and even, with no loose threads. The hole itself should be cleanly cut and not frayed. Keyhole buttonholes, with a rounded end, are often found on high-quality vintage garments and are more durable.

Zippers and Fasteners

  • Zippers: Look for metal zippers, especially on vintage pieces. They are far more durable than plastic ones. The zipper teeth should be smooth and consistent, and the pull tab should be substantial. A sticky or cheap plastic zipper is a sign of poor quality.

  • Hooks and eyes: These should be securely attached and made of sturdy metal. The stitching should be neat and reinforced.

The Hemline: A Sign of Finishing

The hem is one of the most overworked parts of a garment. A well-finished hem is a sign of care and durability.

  • Hand-sewn hems: On high-end vintage garments, especially coats and tailored dresses, you may find a blind hand stitch. This is a subtle, almost invisible stitch that is a hallmark of quality.

  • Machine-sewn hems: A good machine-sewn hem will have straight, even stitches and a generous allowance of fabric folded under, preventing it from unraveling. A narrow, skimpy hem is a sign of a shortcut.

  • Turned and stitched: This is a common and durable hem where the raw edge is turned under once, then turned under again and stitched.

Fit and Form: The Blueprint of a Garment

A garment can have the best fabric and construction in the world, but if the cut is poor, it will never look or feel right. The fit and form of a vintage piece are crucial to its value.

The Grain Test

The way a garment is cut in relation to the fabric’s grain is paramount.

  • Cross-grain: A garment cut on the cross-grain will often twist and distort, especially after washing.

  • On the bias: A bias-cut garment, where the fabric is cut at a 45-degree angle, will have a beautiful drape and stretch. A well-cut bias piece will hang gracefully and flow over the body. A poorly cut bias piece will stretch out unevenly and lose its shape.

  • The hang: Hold the garment on a hanger. It should hang straight and evenly. A dress that is pulling to one side, or a jacket that is sagging in the back, is likely poorly cut.

The Interfacing and Lining

  • Interfacing: Interfacing is a hidden layer of fabric used to give structure to collars, cuffs, and plackets. A good vintage garment will have a substantial, well-fused interfacing that gives these areas crispness without feeling stiff or board-like.

  • Lining: The lining of a garment should be a quality fabric, often a smooth rayon, silk, or Bemberg. The lining should be cut to match the outer garment and should hang freely, without pulling or bunching. It should also have its own clean, finished seams. A cheap, stiff lining is a telltale sign of a low-quality piece.

Beyond the Basics: Advanced Vintage Vetting

Once you’ve mastered the fundamentals, you can look for more subtle signs of quality that differentiate a good vintage piece from a truly exceptional one.

The Label Story

While the label isn’t everything, it can provide clues.

  • Union labels: The presence of a union label, such as ILGWU (International Ladies’ Garment Workers’ Union), is a strong indicator of a garment made in the USA under fair labor conditions, often with a higher standard of craftsmanship.

  • “Made in…” and fabric content: Vintage labels were often more detailed and honest about fabric content. A label that specifies “100% fine wool” or “pure silk crepe” is a good sign.

  • Designer labels: While not all designer vintage is high quality, a well-known name from a reputable era (e.g., a 1950s Dior or a 1970s Halston) is often a guarantee of superior construction and fabric.

The Hand-Finished Touches

Look for signs of hand finishing. A hand-sewn hem, a hand-picked zipper, or a hand-stitched buttonhole are all signs of a garment that was made with time, skill, and care. These are the details that are impossible to replicate with a machine and are a sign of a truly special piece.

Condition and Patina

Quality doesn’t just mean a pristine garment. Vintage pieces will show signs of life. The key is to distinguish between graceful aging and outright wear and tear.

  • Fading: A beautiful, even fade on a pair of vintage jeans or a denim jacket can add character and value. Uneven or patchy fading can be a sign of sun damage or improper care.

  • Mending: A neatly mended tear or a patched elbow on a sweater can be a sign that the garment was so loved and valued that someone took the time to repair it. It’s a testament to its quality and durability.

  • Damage to avoid: Watch out for moth holes, large stains that won’t lift, or extensive fraying at the collar or cuffs that can’t be easily repaired.

Conclusion: The Art of the Hunt

Spotting quality in vintage clothing is a skill that develops with practice. By training your eyes and your hands to notice the details—the tight weave of the fabric, the clean finish of a seam, the substantial feel of a button—you will not only find more beautiful and enduring garments but also gain a deeper appreciation for the art of garment construction. The next time you’re sifting through a rack, go beyond the superficial. Turn the garment inside out, feel the weight of the fabric, and examine the seams. You’ll be surprised at what you find, and you’ll walk away with a piece of history that is not only stylish but also built to last for generations to come.