How to Tailor for Men’s Fashion: Suits and Shirts

by

The Ultimate Guide to Men’s Tailoring: From Suits to Shirts

Introduction

A well-tailored garment isn’t just clothing; it’s a statement. In men’s fashion, especially with suits and shirts, the difference between an off-the-rack piece and a custom-fitted one is the difference between blending in and standing out. This guide cuts through the noise to provide a definitive, actionable roadmap to achieving the perfect fit. We will bypass the fluff and get straight to the “how-to,” arming you with the knowledge to walk into a tailor’s shop with confidence and leave with a wardrobe that truly fits you.

The Foundation of Fit: Understanding Suit and Shirt Anatomy

Before you can effectively communicate with a tailor, you must understand the language. Each part of a suit and shirt has a name and a specific function related to fit.

Suit Jacket Anatomy:

  • Shoulders: The most critical point of a suit jacket. A good fit here is non-negotiable. The seam should sit precisely where your shoulder ends. If it’s too wide, it will droop. Too narrow, and it will pucker.

  • Collar: The collar of the jacket should lie flat against your shirt collar, with no gap. A gap here is called “collar roll.”

  • Lapels: These should lie flat against your chest. A gaping lapel suggests the jacket is too tight across the chest.

  • Chest and Waist: The jacket should button without pulling or straining. The “V” formed by the lapels should be smooth and not stretched. The ideal fit is a gentle taper from the chest to the waist, creating a clean silhouette.

  • Sleeves: The sleeves should be slim but not tight, with enough room for comfortable movement. They should end about a quarter-inch above the wrist bone, revealing a sliver of your shirt cuff.

  • Jacket Length: For a traditional fit, the jacket should cover your seat. A more modern, shorter cut might stop at the crease of your buttocks. A good general rule is that when you stand with your arms at your sides, your thumb knuckles should align with the bottom of the jacket.

Dress Shirt Anatomy:

  • Collar: The collar should sit comfortably without being too tight or too loose. You should be able to fit one finger between the collar and your neck. Any more than that, and it’s too big; any less, and it’s too small.

  • Shoulders: Similar to the suit jacket, the shoulder seam should align perfectly with the edge of your shoulder.

  • Chest and Body: The shirt should be slim through the chest and waist, with no excess fabric billowing out when tucked in. A good fit is snug but not constricting, allowing for full range of motion.

  • Sleeves: The sleeve should be tailored to your arm’s shape, not baggy. The cuff should end at the base of your hand, where your wrist meets your palm.

  • Cuffs: The cuff should be snug enough to not slide up your arm easily but loose enough for comfort. It should be able to pass over a watch without a struggle.

Tailoring a Suit Jacket: A Step-by-Step Guide

Tailoring a suit jacket is a delicate art. Here are the most common and impactful alterations you should consider.

1. Shoulders: The Ultimate Non-Negotiable Alteration

Shoulder alterations are complex and expensive, often costing more than the jacket itself. They involve deconstructing and rebuilding the jacket. The golden rule is: never buy a jacket that doesn’t fit in the shoulders. The only exception is a very minor adjustment, like taking in a tiny amount of excess fabric, but even this is tricky. Focus on finding a jacket with a perfect shoulder fit from the start.

2. Sleeve Length: A Simple but Critical Adjustment

This is one of the most common and straightforward alterations.

  • How to do it: The tailor will mark the new desired length. The ideal length is a personal preference, but the classic fit is for the jacket sleeve to end about a quarter-inch above the shirt cuff. This allows for a clean line and reveals the shirt cuff.

  • Actionable Tip: When getting this done, wear the shirt you intend to wear with the suit. This provides the tailor with the most accurate reference. If you have an expensive shirt with working buttons (a “surgeon’s cuff”), the tailor will need to shorten the sleeve from the shoulder, which is a more complex and costly process. For standard suit jackets, they will simply shorten the sleeve from the cuff.

3. Taking in the Waist: Creating a Sharper Silhouette

A common complaint with off-the-rack suits is the “boxiness” around the waist.

  • How to do it: The tailor will pin the fabric at the seams on the back of the jacket, creating a more tapered fit. They will then sew these new seams to bring in the waist.

  • Actionable Tip: When the tailor is pinning, stand naturally with your arms at your sides. Ask them to pin it so the jacket gently hugs your body, without any pulling or straining when you button it. A good tailor will know to leave enough room for movement and to create a clean, V-shaped silhouette.

4. Adjusting the Jacket Length: Modern vs. Traditional

This alteration is generally discouraged, but possible for minor adjustments.

  • How to do it: A tailor can shorten a jacket from the bottom. However, this risks throwing off the proportions, especially the placement of the pockets.

  • Actionable Tip: Be extremely cautious. If the jacket is excessively long, it’s often better to find a different size. If it’s just a half-inch or so, a good tailor can make the adjustment without compromising the look.

5. Other Common Suit Alterations

  • Letting out the waist: If the jacket is a bit tight, a tailor can often let out the side seams to give you more room.

  • Adjusting the collar: If you have a collar roll, a tailor can sometimes re-attach the collar to the neckline to fix the issue. This is a complex alteration.

Tailoring Dress Pants: The Unsung Hero of the Suit

The pants are just as important as the jacket for a cohesive look.

1. The Hem: The Break, or Lack Thereof

This is the most crucial alteration for pants. The “break” refers to the crease that forms where the bottom of the pants meets your shoe.

  • No Break: The pant leg ends just at the top of your shoe, with no crease. This is a very modern, clean look. Ideal for slim-fit pants and a more contemporary style.

  • Slight Break: The pant leg creates a single, subtle crease where it meets your shoe. This is the most popular and versatile choice, working well for most suits.

  • Full Break: The pant leg bunches up over your shoe, creating a prominent crease. This is a more traditional, classic look.

  • How to do it: The tailor will have you stand in the shoes you’ll wear with the suit. They will then pin the hem to your desired length.

  • Actionable Tip: When getting this done, always wear the shoes you plan to wear with the pants. The heel height and shoe style will drastically affect the final length.

2. Taking in the Waist: A Necessity for a Clean Fit

A properly fitting waist is key to preventing sagging and a sloppy appearance.

  • How to do it: A tailor will take in the waistband from the center seam at the back.

  • Actionable Tip: When the tailor is pinning, the waistband should sit comfortably on your natural waist without a belt. You should be able to fit two fingers into the waistband without any strain.

3. Tapering the Leg: Creating a Modern Silhouette

Most off-the-rack pants are too wide below the knee. Tapering creates a cleaner, more streamlined look.

  • How to do it: The tailor will pin the pants along the inner seam from the knee down to the ankle, creating a more tapered leg opening.

  • Actionable Tip: Ask the tailor to taper the pants to your desired width. A good starting point is a 7-8 inch opening for a modern, slim look, but this depends on your body type. Be cautious not to go too narrow, or you won’t be able to get your foot through the opening.

Tailoring a Dress Shirt: The Details that Make the Difference

A well-fitting shirt is the foundation of any tailored look.

1. Taking in the Body: Eliminating the “Muffin Top”

This is the most impactful alteration for a dress shirt. It eliminates the excess fabric that bunches up around the waist, creating a clean, tucked-in look.

  • How to do it: The tailor will take in the side seams of the shirt, creating a more tapered fit that follows the natural curve of your torso.

  • Actionable Tip: Ask the tailor to pin the shirt so it’s slim but not tight. You should be able to move your arms freely without the fabric pulling. The goal is to eliminate the billowing, not to create a second skin.

2. Adjusting the Sleeves: Length and Width

  • Sleeve Length: This is a simple hemming job. The cuff should end at the base of your hand, covering your wrist bone.

  • Sleeve Width: Many off-the-rack shirts have baggy sleeves. A tailor can take in the sleeve seam to create a slimmer, more tailored fit. This is a game-changer for a clean look.

  • Actionable Tip: Ask the tailor to take in the sleeves from the armpit down. The sleeve should be snug but not restrictive.

3. Adjusting the Cuffs: A Minor Detail with Major Impact

If your cuffs are too loose, they will slide up and down your arm.

  • How to do it: A tailor can move the button on the cuff, making it tighter.

  • Actionable Tip: The cuff should be snug enough to prevent it from sliding up your arm but loose enough to be comfortable. You should be able to slide a finger in, but not your whole hand.

The Tailor-Client Relationship: How to Communicate Effectively

A great tailor is a partner in your style journey. Your ability to communicate your needs is paramount.

  • Be Specific: Instead of saying, “It’s too big,” say, “I’d like to take in the waist about an inch on each side.” This shows you’ve thought about the fit and makes their job easier.

  • Use the Right Terminology: Use the terms from this guide (e.g., “the break,” “tapering,” “collar roll”). It shows you are serious and knowledgeable.

  • Trust Their Expertise (but be firm): A good tailor will offer advice, but you are the client. If they suggest something you don’t like, politely state your preference. For example, “I appreciate that, but I’d prefer a no-break hem.”

  • Try on the Garment: Never leave the tailor without trying on the garment after the alterations are complete. Check for any pulling, bunching, or unevenness.

The Cost of Tailoring: A Practical Breakdown

Tailoring is an investment, but a worthwhile one. Here is a general estimate of costs. These prices can vary widely based on location, tailor’s skill, and complexity.

  • Suit Jacket:
    • Sleeve Shortening: $25 – $45

    • Waist Tapering: $35 – $60

    • Shoulder Alterations: $100+ (often not worth it)

  • Suit Pants:

    • Hemming: $15 – $30

    • Waistband Adjustment: $20 – $40

    • Tapering the Leg: $30 – $50

  • Dress Shirt:

    • Taking in the Body: $20 – $35

    • Sleeve Shortening: $15 – $25

    • Sleeve Tapering: $20 – $40

Conclusion

Tailoring is the secret to a polished, sophisticated look. It’s the difference between wearing clothes and the clothes wearing you. This guide has provided you with the practical knowledge to take control of your wardrobe. You now understand the key areas to focus on, the right questions to ask, and the specific alterations that will make the most impact. Armed with this information, you can transform off-the-rack garments into a wardrobe that feels custom-made, reflecting your personal style and attention to detail. The journey to a better-fitting wardrobe starts with a single, confident step into a tailor’s shop.