How to Use Eyeliner to Create the Illusion of Bigger Eyes

by

The Ultimate Guide to Faking It: How to Use Eyeliner to Create the Illusion of Bigger Eyes

Your eyes are the windows to your soul, and if you’re anything like most people, you want those windows to look as big and bright as possible. While genetics play a significant role in eye size, makeup—specifically eyeliner—is a powerful tool that can dramatically alter their appearance. This isn’t about changing the shape of your eyes but about creating a masterful illusion, a trompe-l’œil that makes them appear wider, more open, and captivating.

This isn’t a guide filled with vague tips. It’s a comprehensive, step-by-step manual designed to empower you with the techniques, products, and precision needed to transform your look. We’ll move beyond the basic winged liner and delve into strategic placements, color theory, and advanced application methods. By the end of this guide, you’ll have a complete arsenal of skills to make your eyes look bigger and more defined than ever before.

Section 1: The Foundation – Choosing the Right Tools and Products

Before we even touch a liner to your lid, understanding your tools is crucial. The right product can make the difference between a flawless line and a smudged mess. Forget the one-size-fits-all approach; we’ll break down what to use and why.

Eyeliner Formulas: A Deep Dive

  • Pencil Eyeliner: The workhorse of the eyeliner world. Pencils are perfect for beginners due to their forgiving nature. They’re great for smudging, creating a soft look, and defining the waterline. Choose a creamy, highly pigmented formula that glides on without tugging. A soft, sharpened pencil is essential for precision.
    • Pro Tip: For a smoky, eye-enlarging effect, use a brown or charcoal pencil instead of black. It’s softer and less harsh, preventing the eye from looking closed off.
  • Gel Eyeliner: Housed in a pot and applied with a brush, gel eyeliner offers a balance between the ease of a pencil and the precision of a liquid. It’s known for its intense color payoff and long-lasting, waterproof formulas. Gel is perfect for creating sharp wings and tightlining.
    • Application Tool: A thin, angled brush is your best friend for gel liner. The angle allows for a controlled application along the lash line.
  • Liquid Eyeliner: The master of precision. Liquid liners, whether in a pot with a dip brush or a pen format, deliver the sharpest, most dramatic lines. They are ideal for creating a crisp wing and defining the upper lash line with an unwavering black.
    • Pen vs. Pot: Pens are more beginner-friendly, offering a felt-tip or brush tip that provides a steady hand. Pot-and-brush liquid liners require more practice but give you the most control over the line’s thickness and shape.

Color Theory for Bigger Eyes

It’s a common misconception that black eyeliner is the only way to go. While a powerful classic, black can sometimes make smaller eyes appear even smaller by creating a stark boundary. The key to making eyes look bigger is to use color strategically.

  • White or Nude Eyeliner: This is the secret weapon. Applying a white or nude pencil to your lower waterline instantly brightens the eye and makes the whites of your eyes appear larger. A nude color looks more natural and less theatrical than a stark white.

  • Brown and Charcoal: As mentioned earlier, brown and charcoal liners offer the definition of black without the harshness. They create a softer shadow, making the eyes look more open and awake. Use these shades for both the upper and lower lash lines.

  • Shimmer and Metallics: A touch of shimmer, like a champagne or rose gold, on the inner corner of the eye can catch the light and make your eyes look wider and more alert. Avoid dark shimmers that can have the opposite effect.

Section 2: The Techniques – Upper Eyelid Mastery

The way you apply eyeliner to your upper lid is the most critical factor in creating the illusion of bigger eyes. We’ll break down the most effective techniques, moving from simple to more advanced.

Technique 1: The Thin-to-Thick Line

This is the cornerstone of eye-enlarging eyeliner. A single, thick line from start to finish will close off your eye. The goal is to create a gradual line that mimics the natural lash density.

  • Step 1: Start Thin. Using a liquid or gel liner, begin a very thin line at the inner corner of your eye, as close to the lash line as possible. You should barely be able to see this line.

  • Step 2: Gradual Thickening. As you move from the inner corner toward the center of your eye, slowly and subtly increase the thickness of the line. The line should be at its thickest directly above your pupil.

  • Step 3: Define the Outer Corner. Continue the line from the center to the outer corner, maintaining a slightly thicker line. Do not create a heavy wing just yet; we will get to that. The line should end exactly where your lash line ends.

Technique 2: The Invisible Liner (Tightlining)

Tightlining is the art of filling in the space between your lashes, making them appear thicker and darker without a visible line on the lid. This technique adds depth and definition without a heavy-handed look.

  • Step 1: Prep Your Eyelid. Lift your upper eyelid gently. You will see the underside of your lash line and the space between the lashes.

  • Step 2: Apply Liner. Using a waterproof pencil or gel liner and a thin brush, carefully dot and press the product into the base of your lashes from underneath. Work in small sections, making sure to fill every gap.

  • Step 3: Check Your Work. Blink a few times to settle the liner. The result should be fuller-looking lashes with no visible line on your lid.

Technique 3: The Modified Wing

A classic winged liner can sometimes make eyes look smaller, especially if the wing is too thick or long. The modified wing focuses on lifting the eye, not dragging it sideways.

  • Step 1: Map the Angle. Instead of following the natural curve of your lower lash line, aim the wing toward the end of your eyebrow. This upward angle creates a lifted, open look.

  • Step 2: The Outer V. From the outer corner of your eye, draw a thin line angled slightly upwards. Then, from the tip of that line, draw a second line back toward your lash line, creating a small, open triangle or “V.”

  • Step 3: Fill It In. Fill in the triangle with your eyeliner. The key here is to keep the wing relatively short and thin. A long, heavy wing can look dated and weigh down the eye.

Section 3: The Techniques – Lower Eyelid Mastery

The lower lash line is often neglected, but it holds immense power in creating the illusion of bigger eyes. The wrong technique here can instantly shrink your eyes, while the right one can make them pop.

Technique 1: The Waterline Brightener

This is the number one trick for opening up the eye. A bright waterline makes the whites of your eyes appear larger and more vibrant.

  • Step 1: Choose Your Product. Select a creamy, long-wearing white or nude eyeliner pencil. Nude is generally preferred for a more natural effect.

  • Step 2: Prep the Waterline. Gently pull down your lower eyelid. The waterline is the inner rim of the eye.

  • Step 3: Glide On. Carefully glide the pencil along your entire lower waterline, from the inner to the outer corner. Apply a few layers until the color is opaque.

Technique 2: The Lower Lash Line Shadow

Instead of a harsh line, creating a soft shadow on the lower lash line adds depth without closing off the eye.

  • Step 1: Use a Soft Pencil. Choose a brown or a soft gray pencil eyeliner. A pencil is ideal for this as it’s easy to smudge.

  • Step 2: Draw a Thin Line. Draw a very thin line just below your lower lash line, starting from the outer corner and stopping about two-thirds of the way toward the inner corner. Do not go all the way to the inner corner, as this will close off the eye.

  • Step 3: Smudge it Out. Immediately after drawing the line, use a small, dense smudge brush or a cotton swab to gently blend the line downward and outward. The goal is to create a soft, smoky shadow, not a defined line.

Technique 3: The Outer Corner Connect

Connecting your upper and lower eyeliner at the outer corner is a common mistake that can shrink the eye. The “outer corner connect” is a subtle, intentional way to define the eye while maintaining a sense of openness.

  • Step 1: Upper and Lower Liner. Apply your eyeliner to the upper lash line using the thin-to-thick technique. Apply a smudged line to the outer third of your lower lash line.

  • Step 2: The Gap. The key is to leave a tiny, invisible gap between the end of your upper liner and the end of your lower liner. This small space is where the magic happens.

  • Step 3: The Light Trick. With a small, precision brush, apply a tiny dot of a shimmery, light-colored eyeshadow (like champagne or pearl) directly into that gap. This highlights the area, creating the illusion of width and making the eye look more open and lifted.

Section 4: Bringing It All Together – The Full Look

Creating the illusion of bigger eyes is a holistic process. It’s not just about a single line; it’s about combining multiple techniques for a cohesive, transformative effect.

The Inner Corner Brightening

This is a non-negotiable step. A bright inner corner brings light to the eye and makes them look more wide-set and alert.

  • Product: Use a shimmery eyeshadow, a highlighter, or a white/champagne eyeliner pencil.

  • Application: Use a small, pencil-shaped brush or your fingertip to apply a small amount of product to the very inner corner of your eye, just in the crease where the upper and lower lids meet. Blend it out subtly.

Lash Curler and Mascara

This is the final, crucial step. Curled lashes open up the eye and make them appear larger, while mascara adds definition and length.

  • Step 1: The Curl. Use a high-quality lash curler. Place it at the base of your lashes, clamp down gently, and hold for 10-15 seconds. Repeat this process in the middle and at the tips of your lashes for a full, sweeping curl.

  • Step 2: The Mascara. Choose a mascara that is both lengthening and volumizing. A waterproof formula will hold the curl better. Apply one coat from the base to the tips of your upper lashes. Then, apply a second coat, focusing on the outer lashes to create a cat-eye effect that elongates the eye.

  • Lower Lashes: For the lower lashes, use a light hand. A thin coat of mascara on the lower lashes can open the eye up. However, a heavy application can create a tired or spidery look.

Section 5: Common Mistakes and How to Avoid Them

Even with the best intentions, it’s easy to make mistakes that negate all your hard work. Let’s address the most common pitfalls.

  • Mistake 1: Heavy, Thick Black Eyeliner. A thick, dark line around the entire eye acts like a frame, and a heavy frame makes a small picture look even smaller. The solution is to use the thin-to-thick technique and softer colors like brown or charcoal.

  • Mistake 2: Lining the Entire Lower Lash Line. Lining the entire lower lash line, especially with a dark color, is the fastest way to make your eyes look small and rounded. The fix is to only line the outer third and smudge it out, or use a brightener on the waterline.

  • Mistake 3: A Downward-Sloping Wing. A wing that is angled downward will drag the eye down and make it look droopy and smaller. The solution is to always angle your wing slightly upward, toward the end of your eyebrow.

  • Mistake 4: Skipping the Lash Curler. Skipping this simple but essential step leaves your lashes pointing straight out, which casts a shadow on the eye and makes it look smaller and less open. The solution is to always, always curl your lashes before applying mascara.

Conclusion: The Art of Illusion

Eyeliner is more than just a cosmetic product; it’s a tool for artistic expression and optical illusion. By mastering the techniques outlined in this guide, you can move beyond simple lines and create a transformative effect that makes your eyes look bigger, brighter, and more captivating.

The key is to understand that the goal isn’t just to add a line but to strategically use light, shadow, and shape to redefine your eye’s natural contours. Experiment with different colors and techniques to find what works best for your unique eye shape. The journey to bigger, brighter eyes is an art, and with these tools, you are now a master of the craft.